Talk:Woodfall

From Zelda Dungeon Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Alright, we have way too many pages for Woodfall. This one, Woodfall (location), and apparently Woodfall (region). For right now, I'll just redirect this page to Woodfall (location), even though I believe it should just be "Woodfall" considering no other Zelda game has this location (I think, not 100% sure). Atticus 22:38, September 1, 2012 (CDT)

Alright, nevermind what I said. I'm crazy. This page should have been redirected in the first place, and Woodfall (region) should be created. Am I correct? Atticus 22:43, September 1, 2012 (CDT)

...I'm really confused. XD So Woodfall (Region) would be the whole swamp, and Woodfall (Location) would be the area where the temple is, right? I'm thinking that maybe we should put the location (or we could put the region if everyone thinks that's better; more pages linking here are probably for the region anyway) just on the Woodfall page, and then specify that the other page is for the region/location. That's what happened with Face Shrine and Face Shrine (Region), so I can't see why we couldn't do it here. If we don't want to do that, then this page should probably be disambiguation, not redirect. Heroine of Time 23:06, September 1, 2012 (CDT)
Is the area outside Woodfall Temple really called Woodfall? I'm looking at the text dump and "Woodfall", when not followed immediately by "Temple", always seems to refer to the entire region (as in "the southern swamp at Woodfall"). Except maybe in the maps, which are somewhat confusing in that they use "Stone Tower" to refer to the entire Ikana Canyon region. Regardless, the "Woodfall" article should be for the region. Disambiguated pages can be built up from there if necessary. << Locke(T·C·P) >> 23:27, September 1, 2012 (CDT)
Yes, the area around the Temple is named "Woodfall" similarly to the other regions. The only canon material suggesting the Southern Swamp is the region is the MM Nintendo Guide. Hyrule Historia, artwork of Termina (Which Uses Other Names such as Ikana Valley), and in-game state "Woodfall" is the region. :) Odd300 :) 17:28, March 12, 2013 (CDT)

Possible change to Southern Swamp

The two Woodfall pages here are quite confusing, isn't Woodfall itself just the Volcano in the middle of the swamp and Southern Swamp the in-game reference/descriptor to the entire region? I can't seem to recall any in-game text refering to the entire area as woodfall. Abc2VE 20:46, October 9, 2012 (CDT)Abc2VE

Here are some quotes:

"You got a map of Woodfall! Now you can find your way around the swamp."

— In-Game

"Wait! You still haven't solved the problem with the swamp at Woodfall!"

— Tatl

"The southern swamp at Woodfall lies in this direction. Be careful."

— Guard

"If you're going off to Woodfall, your timing could not be better."

— Unknown

"The regions consist of the swampland of Woodfall..."

— Hyrule Historia
I think you get the point. :) Odd300 :) 17:43, March 12, 2013 (CDT)
I had forgotten all about this page but, I have looked at this closer since then. Woodfall, by itself, is way too confusing so the page title may need to be adjusted to include "(Region)" in the name or just "Woodfall Region" without parentheses. Then adjust other links aimed toward this page.~~abc2VE