Talk:Twilight

From Zelda Dungeon Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

I've just realised that I made a page named "Curtain of Twilight". This is actually referenced in the game and it makes more sense than this page itself. Twilight, the location, refers to the Twilight Realm and not the element itself. The Curtain of Twilight is basically what this page is referring to and I think this page should be redirected.

Any of you guys agree? Justac00lguy (talk) 09:14, December 23, 2013 (MST)

I always imagined that by "Curtain of Twilight" they simply meant the wall of sorts that separates the two realms, and not necessarily the actual twilight area. Furthermore, the term Twilight Realm directly refers to the actual realm that the Interlopers were banished to. It would be inappropriate IMO to call the Hyrule-covered area the Twilight Realm. That's why we went with this title. I do admit it's not the best name, but it's the best we've got, especially with the very specific uses of the other terms. fused_shadows Complete Fused Shadow.png (T|C|U) 20:00, December 23, 2013 (MST)
It's just that this page refers to a location when in reality it's actually not. The Twilight Realm is the location and the Twilight is basically the element (atmosphere is probably a better word) that shrouds Hyrule. Whereas the Dark World can be referred to as its own world as it's an entirely new Realm. The Twilight is still Hyrule it's just seen in a new light, literally.
I know it's an odd one, but maybe we could just change this to an element page? I'm not sure if we have such (in fact I'm pretty sure we don't). Since more TP pages have the Twilight sections included (pictures an all) it pretty much makes this page redundant as a "location". I'm not sure what we should do as I too don't think it belongs in the other Twilight associated pages. This is just an example of one of those awkward pages. Justac00lguy (talk) 15:45, December 26, 2013 (MST)