User talk:Argentum Kurodil

Hey! Listen! Welcome to our Wiki, Argentum Kurodil!

We're glad that you signed up so that you can edit, build, and shape the Zelda Dungeon Wiki! Before you start editing, why don't you check out some of these useful links and read these basic rules?

• Edit your settings. Make sure you have set up your settings to make the wiki work the way you want it. We have a bunch of customizations that we have spent time creating, and we hope that you utilize them to the fullest.
• Please treat all members with respect. We don't want to have to ban someone because there is an issue between our users.
• Use wikicode and link templates when making edits to properly format pages. Use templates often to save on coding everything.
• If you have some questions, instead of sitting around doing nothing, ask our administration team. They won't bite.
• Head to our help page to find some links to helpful pages that will teach you how to do many things on the wiki.
• Read the FAQ to find the answers to a few common questions.
• Please use proper grammar and strive for good edits.
• Always sign talk pages with four tildes (~~~~). This will automatically sign the page with your username and date.
• Use talk pages to talk about edits on pages. Do not participate in editing wars (i.e. editing a page over and over again to make the page what you think it should be rather than what another member thinks) as they are counter productive and will not solve the problem. Use the talk pages like they were meant to be used.

We hope that you enjoy your time here on the Zelda Dungeon Wiki and that you will help us make lots of really good edits. Keep in mind that the administration team will be watching for quality editors to bring them on to our site staff.

Do you have any initial questions? Feel free to ask on one of our staff talk pages.

Thanks again for joining! Can't wait to see you around!

-- Navi (talk) 11:15, January 9, 2020 (UTC)

Hylian (Sheikah)

That's how the Character Profiles in TotK have it. Sheikah are Hylians. (While Gerudo are not)

- Sanityormadness (talk) 16:29, August 6, 2023 (UTC)

And while I'm here, creating pages like Sage of Fire with no details on the character beyond "this guy exists" isn't very helpful. - Sanityormadness (talk) 16:48, August 6, 2023 (UTC)

That's not how the lore has it. Skyward Sword makes them non-human. *All* Humans are on Skyloft, and at the same time Sheikah are not. You are well aware that Hylians are Human I'm sure.

Besides, one listing of Hylian (Sheikah) and many more of just Sheikah should suggest which trumps.

It's better to have bald pages to be filled in later than not have them at all and risk them never even being made. Argentum Kurodil (talk) 18:07, August 6, 2023 (UTC)

Oh, and this wouldn't even be the only race the Purah Pad gets wrong. It lists the Great Deku Tree as a Korok. He is not a Korok (a race evolved from Kokiri evolved from Hylians through the Deku Tree). He is... A Deku Tree. If Deku Trees outdate Koroks and created Koroks from a non-Deku Tree source, then the Deku Trees cannot themselves be Koroks. If this official yet discontinued Nintendo website is anything to go off, Deku Trees can grow from Deku Seeds like Deku Babas

http://web.archive.org/web/20160309185730/http://zelda.com/universe/pedia/d.jsp

Even two-handed weapons and spears don't list the correct damage. This game is full of lies and inconsistencies, so you'd be well advised to refer back to what is known. Argentum Kurodil (talk) 18:40, August 6, 2023 (UTC)

I'm realising you'll want more examples of incorrect things said in-game and passed off as correct statements. We'll do Champions' Arms, with the Gorons as the example. Fugo says there's only one "soul" to inhabit a Boulder Breaker, so only one can exist at a time. This is not only wrong in AoC, where Daruk's inventory can have many, but even in TotK itself. Yunobo has one permanently, including at the same time as Link. The other three lots all follow a similar pattern. Argentum Kurodil (talk) 19:02, August 6, 2023 (UTC)

If you can't dispute my point then I'll have no course of action but to correct the pages.

And for good measure, I'll give another example just to really emphasise that you can't take this game at its word. Rauru claims to Zelda "But remember, that was a future where you never appeared in this world. And you are here now." We know this is wrong from the start of the game, as the murals depicting the events leading to the birth of the Light Dragon (which occurred after Zelda was sent to the past) already exist in this world of Zelda's. Argentum Kurodil (talk) 05:35, August 8, 2023 (UTC)