Zelda Dungeon Wiki:Featured Article Nominations: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Want an adless experience? Log in or Create an account.
Shoaraphah (talk | contribs) |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
====Support==== | ====Support==== | ||
====Oppose==== | ====Oppose==== | ||
| Line 33: | Line 27: | ||
# Unfortunately, I believe that the very reason stated for this article's nomination is its downfall. The Octorok IS a very notable enemy, and it SHOULD have a very complete article -- but this isn't it. Many sections are small and insufficient. The gallery is expansive, but far from complete, with obvious omissions like the DS titles. The page as a whole seems very haphazard and disorganized; the pictures should probably be spread across the article a bit more to make it seem less like a ton of tiny sections of text. It's hard to get a nomination-worthy page for an enemy with so many appearances, and while it can be done, this is far from it. [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 02:56, December 31, 2013 (MST) | # Unfortunately, I believe that the very reason stated for this article's nomination is its downfall. The Octorok IS a very notable enemy, and it SHOULD have a very complete article -- but this isn't it. Many sections are small and insufficient. The gallery is expansive, but far from complete, with obvious omissions like the DS titles. The page as a whole seems very haphazard and disorganized; the pictures should probably be spread across the article a bit more to make it seem less like a ton of tiny sections of text. It's hard to get a nomination-worthy page for an enemy with so many appearances, and while it can be done, this is far from it. [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 02:56, December 31, 2013 (MST) | ||
# Zenox for HN. Anyhow, I don't tthink this article is up to the standards of what a general enemy page should appear like, I.e. Deku Baba.[[User: A LINK IN TIME|A LINK IN TIME]] ([[User Talk: A LINK IN TIME|talk]]) | # Zenox for HN. Anyhow, I don't tthink this article is up to the standards of what a general enemy page should appear like, I.e. Deku Baba.[[User: A LINK IN TIME|A LINK IN TIME]] ([[User Talk: A LINK IN TIME|talk]]) | ||
====Negated==== | |||
<s>i love the octoroct but also they are kind of annoying to deflect there shots in skyward sword --[[User:Shoaraphah|Shoaraphah]] ([[User talk:Shoaraphah|talk]]) 14:43, June 30, 2014 (MDT)--[[User:Shoaraphah|Shoaraphah]] ([[User talk:Shoaraphah|talk]]) 14:43, June 30, 2014 (MDT) shoaraphah</s> | |||
:Personal like or dislike of a subject is not valid grounds for a vote according to the rules. [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 12:24, July 3, 2014 (MDT) | |||
====Total==== | ====Total==== | ||