Daily Debate: Which is More Important in Zelda Games: Combat or Puzzle-Solving?

As the Zelda fanbase saw more of Tri Force Heroes in the weeks following its announcement, some began to share concerns over the game’s emphasis on team-based puzzle-solving. These fans have identified a growing trend in the Zelda series, as the games have focused less on action and more on puzzles in recent years. These concerns have prompted us all to examine the identity of The Legend of Zelda, to ask what gameplay focus more defines the Zelda experience. So today we invite you to consider which is more important in the series: combat or puzzle-solving.

Some fans have expressed their disappointment with the Zelda series’ growing emphasis on puzzle-solving. They believe that puzzle-solving – as the core gameplay focus – significantly slows the pacing of a game, as players are constantly asked to stop the action and look leisurely for a puzzle’s solution. Additionally, puzzles may significantly diminish a title’s replayability, as most puzzles only have a single solution and players will only find satisfaction in solving them the first time.

These fans share the belief that the ideal nature of the Zelda series instead lies in its combat: something the series has lost sight of over the years. The earliest games in the series were very action-focused (especially Zelda II), often asking players to face cunning enemies in battle rather than slow down and solve a puzzle. However, as the series has progressed – with action being outpaced by puzzles – some think that it has drifted from the gameplay that initially defined it. They want to see a return to the early days of Zelda, with the action that initially set the stage for the series.

Then there are those who believe puzzles are most important when defining the Zelda experience. Puzzle-solving has become a staple in Zelda games, with each new game offering more inventive puzzle-based challenges that gamers must overcome. Even though combat has remained in the series to some extent, puzzle-solving has, noticeably, been more emphasized. Each new dungeon and each new weapon introduced offers many different possibilities for mind-bending puzzles. Even the bosses faced in many modern Zelda games present themselves as large puzzles in and of themselves. The Zelda series has grown into a primarily puzzle-focused experience, and there are fans who wouldn’t have it any other way.

These fans enjoy the degree of creativity and ingenuity that puzzle-solving offers, making players think outside-the-box and tackle challenges in interesting new ways; they believe an over-emphasis on combat may stale the gameplay of a Zelda game too quickly. Nintendo has always proved themselves as masters of game design, making the most of every new addition, so some fans expect the Zelda team to hold themselves to that standard. Fans who appreciate the puzzles in the Zelda series recognize this aspect as a fundamental part of the series, and as something that should continue to thrive.

Where do you stand on this debate? Do you believe the Zelda series should return to an emphasis on combat? Or do you believe the series should continue to focus on puzzle-solving as its defining aspect? Let us know what you think in the comments, and join the Daily Debate!

Comments
Sorted Under: Uncategorized
Tagged With: , , ,