The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time has reigned as “Best Game Ever Made” for over a decade. Needless to say, a game’s true quality is subjective due to the player’s taste, but Ocarina of Time has been the recipient of dozens of awards for most critically-acclaimed game ever made. 1UP, Metacritic, and even the Guinness Book of World Records have recognized its outstanding review scores as recently as 2011.
Slowly creeping past and slyly making its way to the top, however, is Nintendo’s recent smash hit, Super Mario Galaxy. According to GameRankings, Galaxy has an incredible 97.64%, just 0.01 point above Ocarina of Time. In third place is Super Mario Galaxy 2, giving Nintendo complete domination of the Top 3.