3,554
edits
Zelda Dungeon Wiki:Featured Image Nominations: Difference between revisions
Want an adless experience? Log in or Create an account.
Zelda Dungeon Wiki:Featured Image Nominations (view source)
Revision as of 04:58, July 19, 2016
, July 19, 2016Text replacement - "User:Matt" to "User:Emma"
mNo edit summary |
m (Text replacement - "User:Matt" to "User:Emma") |
||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
====Oppose==== | ====Oppose==== | ||
# While this image is of course significant, and it's a high-quality scan, the content is sort of meaningless as a picture feature. This is basically just a bunch of useful information, and that kind of thing doesn't make for a good image; it would make more sense to feature a timeline article instead, or to feature a more impressive but still timeline or Hyrule Historia themed image. A featured picture should be cool-looking, not just mostly information. --[[User:Axle the Beast|Axle the Beast]] 03:02, May 8, 2013 (CDT) | # While this image is of course significant, and it's a high-quality scan, the content is sort of meaningless as a picture feature. This is basically just a bunch of useful information, and that kind of thing doesn't make for a good image; it would make more sense to feature a timeline article instead, or to feature a more impressive but still timeline or Hyrule Historia themed image. A featured picture should be cool-looking, not just mostly information. --[[User:Axle the Beast|Axle the Beast]] 03:02, May 8, 2013 (CDT) | ||
# I have a few problems with it. First of all, it's the idea that a timeline was finally released here that is what's notable, not the image itself. Second, it's not really unique. I mean that there are other Hyrule Historia scans that carry other interesting information too. There's nothing about the image itself that says "this is exceptional on its own." Having a timeline is cool and all, but... the image itself... not anymore than the rest of HH is.— {{User: | # I have a few problems with it. First of all, it's the idea that a timeline was finally released here that is what's notable, not the image itself. Second, it's not really unique. I mean that there are other Hyrule Historia scans that carry other interesting information too. There's nothing about the image itself that says "this is exceptional on its own." Having a timeline is cool and all, but... the image itself... not anymore than the rest of HH is.— {{User:Emma/Sig}} 22:41, May 8, 2013 (CDT) | ||
# I agree with Axle and Matt. Also, it's hard to read the text on the scan. [[User:ZD Wiki Editor|ZD Wiki Editor]] ([[User talk:ZD Wiki Editor|talk]]) 06:01, May 4, 2016 (UTC) | # I agree with Axle and Matt. Also, it's hard to read the text on the scan. [[User:ZD Wiki Editor|ZD Wiki Editor]] ([[User talk:ZD Wiki Editor|talk]]) 06:01, May 4, 2016 (UTC) | ||
| Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
====Support==== | ====Support==== | ||
#I always loved this one. Surrounded by miniblins. They always travel in packs and this artwork captures that perfectly.— {{User: | #I always loved this one. Surrounded by miniblins. They always travel in packs and this artwork captures that perfectly.— {{User:Emma/Sig}} 22:41, May 8, 2013 (CDT) | ||
# It's an epic image, and it also shows how [[miniblins]] battle. And the artwork is great. [[User:ZD Wiki Editor|ZD Wiki Editor]] ([[User talk:ZD Wiki Editor|talk]]) 06:05, May 4, 2016 (UTC) | # It's an epic image, and it also shows how [[miniblins]] battle. And the artwork is great. [[User:ZD Wiki Editor|ZD Wiki Editor]] ([[User talk:ZD Wiki Editor|talk]]) 06:05, May 4, 2016 (UTC) | ||