5,711
edits
Zelda Dungeon Wiki:Featured Article Nominations: Difference between revisions
Want an adless experience? Log in or Create an account.
Zelda Dungeon Wiki:Featured Article Nominations (view source)
Revision as of 09:56, December 31, 2013
, December 31, 2013no edit summary
Justac00lguy (talk | contribs) (→Oppose) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
# While this page does have a decent amount of info, it is still not up to par with what we can do. The formatting is sloppy, the writing is vague, and it doesn't have a nice wiki-looking-like look. [[User:Fused shadows|Fused shadows]] 20:49, January 24, 2013 (CST) | # While this page does have a decent amount of info, it is still not up to par with what we can do. The formatting is sloppy, the writing is vague, and it doesn't have a nice wiki-looking-like look. [[User:Fused shadows|Fused shadows]] 20:49, January 24, 2013 (CST) | ||
# Like what Fused said, the page has a good amount of info. However, it falls short from other great pages from bad formatting, its broad way of writing, and not a good layout/look. [[User:Odd300|:) Odd300 :)]] 13:32, January 27, 2013 (CST) | # Like what Fused said, the page has a good amount of info. However, it falls short from other great pages from bad formatting, its broad way of writing, and not a good layout/look. [[User:Odd300|:) Odd300 :)]] 13:32, January 27, 2013 (CST) | ||
# Unfortunately, I believe that the very reason stated for this article's nomination is its downfall. The Octorok IS a very notable enemy, and it SHOULD have a very complete article -- but this isn't it. Many sections are small and insufficient. The gallery is expansive, but far from complete, with obvious omissions like the DS titles. The page as a whole seems very haphazard and disorganized; the pictures should probably be spread across the article a bit more to make it seem less like a ton of tiny sections of text. It's hard to get a nomination-worthy page for an enemy with so many appearances, and while it can be done, this is far from it. [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 02:56, December 31, 2013 (MST) | |||
====Total==== | ====Total==== | ||
{{NumberColor|- | {{NumberColor|-3}} | ||
===[[Lanayru (Light Spirit)]]=== | ===[[Lanayru (Light Spirit)]]=== | ||
| Line 41: | Line 42: | ||
# Like what Fused and Tael stated, this page has a good amount of information, but the lack of layout/sections makes this page not as good as other pages. This page could be expanded on and is not a page worthy of being nominated. [[User:Odd300|:) Odd300 :)]] 14:48, March 10, 2013 (CDT) | # Like what Fused and Tael stated, this page has a good amount of information, but the lack of layout/sections makes this page not as good as other pages. This page could be expanded on and is not a page worthy of being nominated. [[User:Odd300|:) Odd300 :)]] 14:48, March 10, 2013 (CDT) | ||
#This page, while written well, just doesn't seem like the type of article that would be featured on the main page. Sure it has a lot of information, but it also has a distinct lack of sections, which cause a great wall of text making it much harder for the visitor to find the information they desire. It could also do with some more images and whatnot. A no from me, for now.[[User:Justac00lguy|Justac00lguy]] ([[User talk:Justac00lguy|talk]]) 16:17, December 26, 2013 (MST) | #This page, while written well, just doesn't seem like the type of article that would be featured on the main page. Sure it has a lot of information, but it also has a distinct lack of sections, which cause a great wall of text making it much harder for the visitor to find the information they desire. It could also do with some more images and whatnot. A no from me, for now.[[User:Justac00lguy|Justac00lguy]] ([[User talk:Justac00lguy|talk]]) 16:17, December 26, 2013 (MST) | ||
#I hate to be the conclusive vote here, but... I have to agree with what everyone has said previously. I think this page could be featured in the future -- it's certainly on its way -- but at the moment, it's not ready. Like JC said, it definitely could use some organizing and some nice headers to break it up, and more images would be good. Besides, it still has not been updated with the ability to combine references, which was added a long time ago. Speaking of references, the second half of the page -- meaning the third and fourth paragraph -- are severely lacking in them for some odd reason. Yeah, there's still a lot that could be done here. [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 02:56, December 31, 2013 (MST) | |||
====Total==== | ====Total==== | ||
{{NumberColor|- | {{NumberColor|-5}} | ||
{{Clear}} | {{Clear}} | ||
| Line 104: | Line 106: | ||
====Total==== | ====Total==== | ||
{{NumberColor| | {{NumberColor|2}} | ||
{{Clear}} | {{Clear}} | ||