5,770
edits
Want an adless experience? Log in or Create an account.
→Rewriting Articles
Tippetarius (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
Hi Tippetarius! I had two things I wanted to ask you. First of all, are you a part of the Zelda Dungeon Discord server? We have a text channel there for the wiki that might make communication easier. Second of all, I was curious about some of the edits you've made. I'm pretty impressed by the high quality of your edits, but I'm a little confused by the things you replace at times. The [[Bunnio's Wife]] page is the most confusing to me, since it was pretty well-written to begin with but you completely rewrote it and removed the references. In other instances, like the ''Twilight Princess'' section of the [[Iron Boots]] page, you also rewrote some information that seemed to be fine and removed a couple of points in the process. Is there a reason you did this? Thanks! [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 19:20, May 5, 2019 (UTC) | Hi Tippetarius! I had two things I wanted to ask you. First of all, are you a part of the Zelda Dungeon Discord server? We have a text channel there for the wiki that might make communication easier. Second of all, I was curious about some of the edits you've made. I'm pretty impressed by the high quality of your edits, but I'm a little confused by the things you replace at times. The [[Bunnio's Wife]] page is the most confusing to me, since it was pretty well-written to begin with but you completely rewrote it and removed the references. In other instances, like the ''Twilight Princess'' section of the [[Iron Boots]] page, you also rewrote some information that seemed to be fine and removed a couple of points in the process. Is there a reason you did this? Thanks! [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 19:20, May 5, 2019 (UTC) | ||
: I'm sorry for any trouble I might've caused. It wasn't that I saw anything particularly wrong with the articles -- I just thought they sounded a little funny as I was reading them -- in the case of the Iron Boots, specifically, the ''Twilight Princess'' section seemed a little unnecessarily informative...I appreciate you reaching out to me about it, though, and I'll happily revert my edits (unless someone else has already done so) if they were made in error. [[User:Tippetarius|Tippetarius]] ([[User talk:Tippetarius|talk]]) 00:13, May 6, 2019 (UTC) | : I'm sorry for any trouble I might've caused. It wasn't that I saw anything particularly wrong with the articles -- I just thought they sounded a little funny as I was reading them -- in the case of the Iron Boots, specifically, the ''Twilight Princess'' section seemed a little unnecessarily informative...I appreciate you reaching out to me about it, though, and I'll happily revert my edits (unless someone else has already done so) if they were made in error. [[User:Tippetarius|Tippetarius]] ([[User talk:Tippetarius|talk]]) 00:13, May 6, 2019 (UTC) | ||
::No trouble caused -- I just wanted to consult with you and see if there was a reason! As I said in my previous messages, I think your edits have been really high quality and you've made some great improvements. If you think something sounds funny when reading it, it's completely fine to reword it. I'd just like to ask that you be careful not to remove any information unless it's explicitly incorrect. It's far better to be over-informative than under-informative. And don't worry about reverting your edits; I changed the Bunnio's Wife page back since it was the most dramatic change, but I don't think the Iron Boots edits were bad, they just seemed unnecessary to me. Thank you for your quick reply and I hope you keep editing! [[User:Heroine of Time|Heroine of Time]] ([[User talk:Heroine of Time|talk]]) 00:32, May 6, 2019 (UTC) | |||