Go_Dark_Link
If there ever was one
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2011
Yeh, I figured as much. I realize that there's not much I can say to defend myself, in fact your reasoning is similar to how I play, even if we risk losing a townie we still need to move forward, never stagnant.
The best thing I can do is probably dig through one last time tomorrow and look for anything off, maybe I can find a better target, idk, we'll see .
Don't know if actually town or really good mafia attitude to make people trust him, but this post sort of makes me trust him more. Like I said, it might be a ploy to sound like he's willing to die for the town so people will think he is town, but if it is he is very good at it.
Does this count as the day's first roleclaim? There are two allowed per day, according to the rules and we're coming down to the deadline here, so unless the votes are going to shift to another person I think, if no one has a better idea, that PokaLink should claim before he is lynched.I will confirm that I am the commuter.
And justa I think you should be investigated because you are leading the town.
I always like to trust people in Mafia games, but half claimed players have that ere of doubt over there head. MF being investigated is the logical way to settle this dispute and it's not scummy, odd, out of character, or tactical. It's perfectly logical that the Cop would investigate MF, he's not fully confirmed yet. Although, remember, MF usually claims at odd times and usually when he doesn't even need to claim. You could argue that's the same case here; however he claimed at a time when he was in trouble and he claimed the most obvious role, The Commuter. We had literally just established there was a commuter and you think there is nothing strange about that? Either way, this is something of like the Cop to investigate, for one, my own peace of mind, and two, to potentially uncover someone who is fake claiming.
I agree that it is weird that just after learning of the Commuter existing we happened to find him in Music, but there are a couple things off with this. Even if MF is investigated and someone claimed to have done this tomorrow or whenever, would you then not trust that person's claim like you are not trusting Music? So even if an investigation is wasted on him it won't confirm anything? I say wasted because, while I don't disagree investigating him is a bad idea, like Deku said it is quite possibly just going to be a wasted investigation due to his role. The other thing is, what if the cop happens to die tonight after we didn't lynch Music because he was going to investigate him? Then blame starts flying around, just like in Members vs Mods. You might get suspected because you wanted the cop to do something and then the cop randomly died, so maybe the mafia knew who the cop was and were just waiting to get rid of him. Which means maybe Music is mafia, and maybe the cop died so he wouldn't be able to say anything on who he was, etc etc. I know this might be a sort of paranoid way of thinking, but there's so much that could go wrong that you have to remember, even if music is investigated that does never make it confirmed that he is who he says he is. Death is the only way to 100% confirm someone in this game, either that or a modconfirm. That's what I think is wrong about this sort of plan you have.