Actually, the wiki says almost all commuters are Town-aligned:
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Commuter
Don't worry, I had someone correct me in the same way... in this game...
o
EBW
GDL, I didn't see you mention a dreaming god. Mind finding it for me? (sorry if I'm blind and I missed it!)
EBW again
LG: Who are you most suspicious of? I'll tell you if you tell me
Definitely
JC. My main thing right now is that he keeps pursuing MF. I believe MF's commuter claim, and so the way he keeps pressuring MF and saying cop should investigate him to waste an investigation is really rubbing me the wrong way. He also keeps/kept targetting the "easy" players, so to speak, such as Poka and Fig.
Another thing is that at the very beginning of Days 2 and 3 he was restating what other people were saying. (I swear if I quote one thing wrong i'm going to freak out because there will be no way to fix it...)
So Vig killed Koki (hopefully he/she didn't make themselves too obvious to the Mafia) and if seems the SK targeted Alit. However it seems like someone else targeted Alit:
The SK, who I assume is the Villager (mainly because of the reference to going back to his village), left the room where Alit was and then Mafia entered the now empty room with no target in sight. Basically Mafia attempted to NK Alit as did the SK. I'll post some more tomorrow, possibly on the preceeding day.
I suppose it's not fair saying he's restating the vig thing because only a couple people posted before him that day, but I find it odd that he got the mafia action wrong. I guess it would be easy to misread the night scene though, but could have been just trying to throw people off by getting it wrong?
MF, your actions on Day one were slightly off. Seeing as a few people have raised an eyebrow at you, what is your response?
I feel like he's not even trying here. "your actions are slightly off," that could mean anything. He could have been way more specific about this. "You did X, which I think is scummy." Also, note that this is to MF. I've already said that I believe MF, I've also said that mafia would most likely try to lynch the commuter. hmmmmmmm
As much as I considered zooming in on MF, Pokalink's quick response to join the lynch seems out of nowhere. Then again I've seen Poka go with gut instinct before, so this isn't entirely out of character for him.
MF, your vote on the previous day really confused me. I thought it was kind of obvious what Koki was trying to do and I brought light to this in case people started to jump on the lynch. You kind of dodged that though and said you voted mainly because he used a WIFOM situation. Can you at least explain why that's lynch worthy? I'd also like you to state your reasoning for baiting the Mafia Role Cop to target you specifically. Why not bait the Mafia kill? Why would the Mafia Cop fall for this?
k well I guess he elaborates here, but like... he could have said that earlier. You know, BEFORE he took everyone else's accusations.
Also note how he defends Poka. Now he hounding him. jsin
Anyone notice Fig voted for Pancake but then removed it near the end of the day?
Offhandedly throwing suspicion onto Fig. Possibly indirectly starting a bandwagon? We now know Fig is town. JC could have wanted this. Perhaps a possible mafia role cop happened to target Fig?
Ah ok, it's just that you seemed very suspicious of him even after Unvoting. It was as if you were still pushing for his lynch without actually voting, which would kind of allow you to slip under the table and go unnoticed if he was mislynched.
Still making Fig sound sketchy while ending the conversation so Fig didn't have much to respond to.
I'm here and I'm voting for MF (officially... Vote: MF)
I was stepping back on this decision to see if MF could probably justify what I thought were odd actions on Day One that seem sort of out of character in a way. I don't like his vote on Koki one bit, especially when I thought it was obvious what he was doing. I don't buy his reasonings either, and the way he drawed attention to himself, via the Mafia Role Cop, was just, again, odd. Not much to go on today, but I'm set with this lynch.
Just gonna leave this here.
Ugh I'm torn between voting between MF and Pokalink at the moment.
We need some perspectives on this. Viral and Leslie, what are your thoughts?
The easy targets. Note the inactives that he calls out. Leslie barely posted (and then last minute joined the Fig wagon). Viral is only just now becoming more into the game, but at the time he had hardly posted. He didn't call on Heroine or Mizuki or Da Vinci or Vergo or Fly or Stitch or Thareous. Why specifically those two? Are there other mafia hiding among the people barely contnributing (I'm mainly concerned about everyone but Heroine because she's just now getting into the game (i'm so proud of her, contributing this much on Day 3
))?
...after that he has a weird obsession with Fig's character and possibly him killing koki and Fig's lynch (that he may or may not have indirectly started).
Err Thar, in reference to your post about GDL, do you think it's possible his knowledge of the SK came from the Mafia Role Cop?
Offhandedly casting suspicion on GDL, another person I think is town. Purposely sowing more seeds of doubt in people's minds? Perhaps the possible Mafia Role Cop did indeed confirm GDL as town roleblocker and he's still trying to get him lynched?
Right now the main people who I'm suspicious of are:
Pokalink, see my vote; BlackKirby, seems to be avoiding discussion until when I called him up on it; DekuNut, err this one I have nothing to back up on just yet; Musicfan, see previous day and I think we should still be wary despite his claim.
Poka, easy target. (I'm honestly not sure what I think of him, he does act suspicious imo but JC's persistence of him throws me off. I'm considering a Usurper role.) Kirby, I don't see how Kirby's avoiding discussion, he regularly posts his thoughts. That's just nothing on Deku sooo. And, the lovely MF, of course. I think the latter 3 are town because of this, or in MF's case, at the very least not harmful. Possibly hypothetical MRC on Deku as well? (is their cop 1-shot? Mine was in KI mafia. Anyway now that I'm thinking about it if MRC is 1-shot then I'm thinking it was used on Deku and Deku might have some sort of powerful PR.)
But, if he is who he claims, then there wouldn't be a result from that.
If he's Town then it's pretty obvious he's telling the truth. A Townie fake claiming at this stage would be really stupid (sorry, only word I could think of, lol). Of course this means nothing if he's the GF, but there's always that slight chance with the Cop.
The Cop should never come out to confirm a player, they should only come out if they get a guilty result. So, if MF is investigated, and the Cop doesn't claim, we move on with that in mind and suspicion on MF drops completely. However, if the Cop states they got a guilty result then we know what to do. All of this works out in theory, but they're plenty of things that can go wrong, but that's a risk we always have to take.
This... isn't really answering the question, imo. (i know there wasn't a question but I feel like this response doesn't fit with the quote paired. And it might just me but it makes little sense. If it's day 4 and the godfather is dead, Cop should definitely come out and say the people they can confirm as town so they can narrow down mafia more. And, since I believe MF is the commuter, the cop would just be wasting an investigation.
One final thing... The whole Koki ordeal.
And MF, I think this is something we should discuss tomorrow. I have a feeling what Koki is doing, or at least attempting to do.
I feel like he's purposely making Koki's claim thing sound very suspicious, which contradicts this post here:
Ahh my bad, I was trying to divert attention away from you, namely MF.
where he says he was trying to get attention away from it. I feel like if he was trying to get attention away from it he could have just said nothing. Also if he knew Koki's intentions, as he said the post before it:
Just curious, but was your tactic, the slight claim an all, to avoid a Mafia attack? Because that's what I thought you were doing, which is a shame why the Vig targeted you, but oh well mistakes happen.
why didn't he say so? Why be all ambiguous about it instead of mention support for it, like fused did? And another thing, why was there even a need to draw attention away from it? If he wanted to protect Koki he could have supported it instead of "I no what ur doin
"
