It's pretty much someone else's artwork scaled down to avatar size. Could use a bit more creativity, in my opinion. But the picture itself isn't too shabby, so I guess you'll get a 6/10.
First off, so I don't get mod killed you get a 7/10... Ganny...
Second: its official art from "Archie Comics" I could almost care less for them (they have like ONE character in their Sonic comic I like lawl) but they have some pretty nice artwork.
Third: .... if I tried to make my own avatar it'd end up looking like some 5 year old made it. True story. c:
7/10. I had to do a double take, because my first thought was that the shadow across the nose was his mouth in some sort of anime crazy expression. After that initial setback though, I like it. Very dramatic pose.