To be honest, there isn't really anything that makes me want to vote yet, so if I had to vote right now, I wouldn't. There's no point in my giving my input when the name would be totally random, so I think you should let us try to build our own suspicions over the next two or so days. I understand that you are trying to get us all to become suspicious of others, but that's something that a Mafia would do. I just generally let everyone get on with it...it's a decent plan though I guess.
1. Saying you if you HAD to vote you WOULDN'T makes ZERO sense. Now answer this question: If you HAD to vote WHO would you vote for?
2. Who are you addressing? If it's me, then I never said we should rush to vote, but at least try our best in the next three days to come to a voting decision since NO VOTE is not really an option. Per rules, someone has to be lynched. (
Unless of course NO ONE VOTES but is that really an option Mod?)
3.
The blue stuff: I disagree with you here. I'm getting a little irritated with people saying that pro-activeness is scumtell. Yes, it is something the mafia would do, but people need to be pro-active in scum hunting or we'll never going to find the scum. How else do you play the game? I'm going to say this one more time and then I'll shut-up about it: the scum are not going to come out and say "Lynch me, I'm scum!" We have to find them and expose them.
@Awesome-I was wrong? Maybe you're defending a newer player so you can take out the more seasoned players.
With this I need to make a point: This is simply
WIFOM. What this boils down to is your coming up with a lot of "maybes". Maybe this, maybe that. Maybe I'm scum, maybe I'm not. Maybe I'm misleading you, maybe I'm helping you. Ultimately your making the judgement call, but you need more clues/evidence before to back your case up. You're implying that I'm scum. What you need to ask yourself is why do you really think I'm scum. Is it something like WIFOM? If it is, then your argument holds no weight.
^I did not edit that post I swear :O
What sucks is that there are 24 suspects in the game. That's a lot of people to investigate. We have 3 days left. Since I don't know how much time I can spend on the game between know and then, I'm going to go ahead and provide an analysis on a few of the players. I hope I can do everybody before deadline, but I'm going to start with the lurkers because there are bound to be a least a few scum among them.
Starting with people with the fewest post to the most:
Chise: Made 2 post both insightful
Jetter: Made 2 post also both insightful.
Insightfulness is not a scum or townie tell though.
Master Link: Strikes me as a newbie. Saying he didn't understand the abbreviations was gave it away, coupled with fact that I not sure if I 100% agree with all his posts. It's hard to read newbies though if they don't post much. (BTW I feel so foolish now about asking who Master Link was earlier >.<) (3 posts)
Axle the Beast: His posts contain nothing but theory. He hasn't posted in the game in a while (I'm sure he's pretty busy) so I'd like to see him comment on the current developments. (3 posts)
TheSkywardSword: Most of her posts are fluff (nothing relevant or constructive) (3 posts)
Ver-go-a-go-go: Of all the "lurkers" his posts bothers me the most. Most of it is fluff. Then he's very iffy about Draco and then he says watch out for the "actives". This may not be much at all but it's the way he said it that bugs me. Like he's pointing the finger in a particular direction kinda early. I dunno but IGMEOY Ver-go! (3 posts)
Krazy Kyuubi: Pretty much says over and over that he has no idea what's going on. My advice to Krazy: READ, READ, READ! Formulate ideas and suspicions as to who the scum might be. Contribute to discussions and help us lure out the scum. (3 posts)
So my main suspect out of all of these is
Ver-go, but it's really hard to tell until these people POST MOAR!