So
@Nathanial Rumphol-Janc
I really appreciate you coming here. I also really appreciate your transparency and communication.
I do have one question for you.
So, just merging the two forums, incorporating both cultures is a scary thought, as it is indeed change. A lot of things will end up different, most likely not in a good way, nor a bad way.
However, what is in it for us, both the communities of ZI and ZD? In short, what will changes will happen that will serve as a benefit for this forum, and that of ZI? What will you do, that will be a clear improvement for both forums?
This is a very good question and I think it's one that is on the minds of many at ZD that are trying to accept the fact this is really happening. So, the big thing here is that there is going to be uniformity. I can't tell you what the policies will be, the rules, punishments, and all that jazz because the two mod/admin teams haven't started full discussions on this yet, though we've made some progress. But there will be a united front. There will be equality in treatment of everyone - admins/mods/admins/site staff, and what have you. Equality is very important and while I don't have any exact details as they are still be worked out, this will be the focus of things moving forward post merge.
So, based on the complaints I have seen, this should be a welcomed "change" in terms of attitude and mentality. You can also feel more secure in that I'll be here - this likely isn't a security for anyone here just yet, but I can ensure there is no delay on responses and decisions, and if corruption in the mod/admin ranks is happening that it will be dealt with.
One complaint I have seen is that Mases is too hands off. He's still the boss, but under the ZI flag I "am the Boss Man" as it were (a literal nick name staff gave me that turned into a video series). Mases's work at ZI will mostly be on behind the scenes stuff, plus his mailbag. Meanwhile, I will be the one making sure everything goes like clockwork. Obviously I will be delegating the forum moderation and admining to the trusted mods and admins from both communities, but I won't just hand them all the keys and walk away. I'll still be actively involved in the community and helping staff address concerns, while also helping members out too when need be. The only way an equality standard in policies can prevail is when accountability is in place - and that starts at the top. With me being the new "top guy" for the forum folks to come to, I hope to prove that what I am saying isn't just words meant to make you like me - it's what I truly feel and what our collective teams feel too.
So, the benefits to ZD will be a more conhesive staff unit with accountability and equal treatment across the board, regardless of position.
The benefits to ZI's community is first and foremost, it gives us an already active group of people. Ever since you and a handful of other ZD people came over to our boards to check them out, we've had 4 or 5 old timers from our boards come out the woodworks. As the boards get more and more active, I see this happening more and more. As they say, if you build it, they will come. And for the old ZI forum folks to come back the biggest thing they really want is an active forum community. Even as mentalities change, they care far more about an active and friendly community than being a giant group of trolls.
So it will reinvigorate our long standing members. Beyond that, it allows for me to crossover forums with the rest of Zelda Informer's community and outreach, giving a consistent flow of new members into the boards. It's really hard to promote and encourage crossover to a dead forum without a skin. Mases has ensured me that skinning the boards is important (basically a ZD themed skin and a ZI themed skin). I'd assume the ZI skin would be default due to the banner it flies under, but really I am a big promoter of community health and forum growth. Where as at ZD the forums may have been a bit of an afterthought at times, I view that as an integral part of the site that works in sync with the rest of our site.
I also think a lot of people here may find they really enjoy the content ZI makes once they give it a chance.
It's a shame my thread was locked however..... Oh well, I do agree that it got way too off topic.
Indeed. What lead to this (thread derailing) is a topic I talked about briefly with the current ZD forum staff. It's something we are looking to address. Because locking a thread doesn't treat the cause (thread derailing), it treats the symptom. There will be some form of a policy after the merge that will take care of thread derailing before it reaches a point of needing to be locked. I feel terrible your otherwise productive thread had to be shut down, but there wasn't any policies currently in place to really deal with it. I wasn't even sure if the mods would lock the thread when I asked them. I just didn't want to overstep. But, I do want there to be transparency between all of us.