I'm just gonna start this off by saying that I think your reasonings here are slightly dangerous. I have a town lean on funnier and ME myself, mind you, but for different reasons. On the contrary, funnier's hard defence of YIGA would have made me more suspicious of him if I didn't already believe he was town.
Not usually, no. We normally rely on flavour more than anything. PMs don't get revealed until the end game.
Oh wow, this is really helpful.
So you're saying Minish was killed by the mafia, Zachie was killed by the Vig, and Deku was killed by the SK?
This is interesting then. At first I thought Deku was killed by the Vig, but with this new knowledge, I decided to take a look back through Deku's posts and see what stood out. The only thing I noticed was him saying earlier that he'd lynch funnier over Bok. In fact, most of his posts were in response to/disagreeing with funnier. I doubt funnier is mafia, but I do agree with others in that his playstyle seems... off, somehow this game. Like he's playing like his town self, but something seems different and I can't quite put my finger on it. Looking back, I'm actually starting to get reminded of his play in Korra 3, in that his play was reminiscent of his town self, but there seemed to be an air of independence about him. This is just a hunch more than anything, and it's not very concrete, but something to keep in mind for later. I'm not saying I think he's the SK, more that I wouldn't be surprised if he is.
Remind me to be bad at reads when I play with you. First the Bulba game that we're currently in and now this one. Have some more faith in my scumhunting skills, man!
Anyway, since I desire nothing more than to make you happy funnier, I'll give you a reads list!
inb4 my reads are right and I get scum read for it lel
Town:
Kylo Ken - I've said what I can about him. He hasn't come in since to say anything that would change my opinion, however I must say that I'm not sure how I feel about him disappearing towards the end of the day yesterday and today. I'll give him a bit to make another post with his thoughts though.
Aaaand of course just as I finish writing this, he appears XD
funnier6 - This is just because he's not playing like he does as scum, but I am definitely keeping in mind what I said above about the SK.
Maniacal Engineer - This is probably controversial, but I guess it's harder to read people when you don't know their meta. Anyway, while most of his posts have been short, his thoughts have been very consistent throughout and all his posts seem quite fair. I might need to read him again though since most other people seem to be more unsure of him. It's possible that I'm missing something.
Ayano Keiko - Nice and active, consistent in his thoughts and opinions, and genuinely seems to be trying to solve the game. He's paying attention and most of his reasoning is fair enough.
Lone_Garurumon - Just because of the Miller claim. No real reason to disbelieve it at this point.
Null
DarthWolf - I had a town lean on him previously, but I'm unsure now because he hasn't been contributing much. I liked his attempt to spark discussion during day one, but the rest of his 6 posts have been NAI really.
NekoLily - Unsure at this point. She doesn't say a ton, but I got that impression for Death Note too (pretty sure that's the only other game I've played with her) in which she was town. Don't really have enough to read her either way.
Spider-Bok - He had a valid reason for laying low earlier on, and he's starting to come back in full swing. Feeling inclined to town read, but haven't seen enough just yet. One or two more posts from him will likely put him up higher.
Mido - I always find Mido hard to read, because he largely plays the same way whether he's town or scum. I'm not sure what to think because his Day 1 seemed mostly focused on YIGA, but his reasoning was fair enough (I used the same reasoning to vote him over funnier). But something about it concerns me, because YIGA is a really easy mislynch to get away with as scum, and he spearheaded it. So I'm wary of him.
All Might - I'm not sure what to think of him either. He plays really well as town and scum usually, and sarcasm and jokes are characteristic of him as either alignment. I admit I haven't been following him very closely, and he's kind of hard to read since we're both playing in another game together atm, so I'm definitely going to have to re-read him.
Karu, Libk, TattooArtist, walrusdawson, CheffOfGames - Need to see more from you friends.
As it stands, I don't have any true scum leans rn, but of the people on my null list, I'm feeling the most unsure of Mido. I would also be OK with lynching any of the inactives. Although, truth be told, I haven't really been paying as much attention in this game as I should be, so give me some time to re-read most of the thread before I really post again.