Game Thread The Clone Saga: A Spider-Man Mafia 3

[Ragnarokio]

cool duck fact

 

[Morbid Minish]

@ExLight @Silverfish
After reading it over, I will share it

I have reason to believe that the character "Daredevil" is currently mafia

Why the heck is Daredevil mafia?

 

[Skystone]

I want to emphasize, in the vein of Dusky and Tevish, that SMS's refusal to out the mafia is illogical. If he outs only one, then the others have impetus to kill him -- and they must in order to best protect themselves. If, however, he outs them all, then killing him no longer furthers their pursuit of victory, but is merely a pointless act of vengeance, and does not help them win the game.

Also, by hiding names, he prevents townies with night kills from whittling the numbers down even faster than by lynching.

 

[The Sun Fan]

cool duck fact

ty

 

[Ragnarokio]

thats probably something that you'd have rather sent to the daily bugle anonymously to minimize risk to yourself but idk if it matters that much

 

[ExLight]

@ExLight @Silverfish
After reading it over, I will share it

I have reason to believe that the character "Daredevil" is currently mafia

I uh
thanks we'll keep that in mind for the next trivia night

 

[Duskyblue]

@Skystone @Tevish Szat @Duskyblue @Paranoid King

Sorry, I have no vote.

 

[The Sun Fan]

Why the heck is Daredevil mafia?

I'm... not 100% sure, I could be wrong.
My duck fact hints me towards them being mafia, I didn't want to say because it wasn't very clear to me.

 

[ExLight]

I want to emphasize, in the vein of Dusky and Tevish, that SMS's refusal to out the mafia is illogical. If he outs only one, then the others have impetus to kill him -- and they must in order to best protect themselves. If, however, he outs them all, then killing him no longer furthers their pursuit of victory, but is merely a pointless act of vengeance, and does not help them win the game.

Also, by hiding names, he prevents townies with night kills from whittling the numbers down even faster than by lynching.

it isn't illogical and we should trust them since they have the details we don't

 

[The Sun Fan]

thats probably something that you'd have rather sent to the daily bugle anonymously to minimize risk to yourself but idk if it matters that much

see, now, that's what someone not in their first Zinger game might think to do

 

[ExLight]

we can just lynch them if something goes wrong with the lunch lynch
or even if mafia doesn't try to go after them

 

[Ragnarokio]

I want to emphasize, in the vein of Dusky and Tevish, that SMS's refusal to out the mafia is illogical. If he outs only one, then the others have impetus to kill him -- and they must in order to best protect themselves. If, however, he outs them all, then killing him no longer furthers their pursuit of victory, but is merely a pointless act of vengeance, and does not help them win the game.

Also, by hiding names, he prevents townies with night kills from whittling the numbers down even faster than by lynching.

yes he's clearly not telling us the full story and has basically said that he won't because it would harm him or others to do so. I'm fine with him feeding us mafia one at a time as long as he continues doing that. I assume he's only doing that becuase it works out to his own win condition which is clearly seperate from the town's, but i think for the time being it seems to be a good arrangement.

 

[Duskyblue]

it isn't illogical and we should trust them since they have the details we don't

That's exactly why I am NOT trusting him.

 

[Ragnarokio]

he also seemed hesitant to even out CL, and i assume he only did it under threat of lynch. Its probably the case that even just outing one mafia member might heavily jeapordize himself, which further suggests that the deal he's struck with us favours us more than it favours him, and he only made it because he felt it was his only way out of losing today.

 

[ExLight]

That's exactly why I am NOT trusting him.

we should though
sometimes telling the full truth backfires