I love them both.
I'll start with Star Wars. The story is very well planned outl the special effects are great and the whole way it was done was genius. I loved it all and I watch the spin off series too, I love all the characters and if anyone asks me what religion I am, I say Jedi
I like the force concept too, but I think 4, 5 and 6 are a lot better then 1, 2 and 3.
But then...LotR happens. I have to say Lord of the Rings definitely favours over Star Wars. For one thing, I'm a Zelda fan for the same reason, LotR is more like Zelda. I love all the races, the story, the hobbits, the location. It's all amazing and makes me dream that I could live in Middle Earth. I loved reading The Hobbit and I can't wait until the movie comes out. My imagination is just a lot more into LotR. It actually changed my life. The best trilogy of films in history, in my opinion.