The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword, no doubt about that!
The problem is if it goes by votes, Skyrim will win because Im pretty sure their fanbase is bigger than ours. But It shouldnt and if it doesnt It still would be a Great match up. This is also the Hardest Zelda Game since Zelda II. So in toughness Skyrim and Skyward Sword might be evenly matched now =)
Average length for a console Zelda is about 60 to 70 hours. Average length for a Dragon Age game is over 80 hours. Average Elder Scrolls game is 200 to 400 hours.Skyward Sword beats the Dragon Age games in size! 50-100 Hours is not short and easy to replay, this is no ordinary Zelda game! Skyward Sword will also require tons of tactical play with every single enemy being a precision challenge.
I wouldn't be extremely surprised if Skyrim won, but Skyward Sword is far from out of the contest.
Average length for a console Zelda is about 60 to 70 hours. Average length for a Dragon Age game is over 80 hours. Average Elder Scrolls game is 200 to 400 hours.
Except that all that time in those games is quality. It takes them many years to finish each of the TES games, where in the same time they turn out three or four Zeldas.Quantity does not determine quality.
Yea, this is about exactly right.Skyrim will win simply because it's Skyrim.
It has HD graphics, acheivements, an immense amount of hype, and other things that critics love.
Skyward Sword on the other hand is on the Wii which already makes biased critics disappointed, that, and it doesn't have dem HD realistix grafIXx. Realistically, they will both be fantastic games, but I believe Skyward Sword will be the more memorable experience while Skyrim will be GOTY simply because it's massive and will last 100+ hours.
Perhaps I'm not making any sense, but I just think from the average critic viewpoint, Skyrim seems more GOTY material. That, AND a massive army of fanboys will attack them if Skyrim doesn't win.
Except that all that time in those games is quality. It takes them many years to finish each of the TES games, where in the same time they turn out three or four Zeldas.
Well isn't Zelda an Action Adventure RPG technically?Skyrim may win on individual gaming sites but Skyward Sword will take the crown on Metacritic and Game Rankings.
It's like comparing Apples to Oranges-RPGs to Action-Adventure Games.
I determine These will probably be the list of nominations.I'd probably have to say one of these games: Assassin's Creed: Revelations, Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim or The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword. Batman: Arkham City might have a chance. And I don't see an FPS making it up there. But if there was going to be one, I would say Battlefield 3.
Quantity does not determine quality.