Alit claimed Miller though. The mafia would've known he was town, and therefore that his claim was true. Probably wouldn't have been my personal choice, but I can understand why they may have gone for him.
I have a miller modifier so anyone who investigates me will have me show up as mafia despite me being town. I assume this is because I chose a villain character but randed town.
Sorry, I didn't see this until after I posted.