Pretty much everything that TRLahti said two posts above me is correct.
First off, I never understood why people try to compare two games that shouldn't even be compared in the first place. These games are complete polar opposites, different developers, different consoles, concepts, etc.
With that being said, even if you were to state reasons why Skyward Sword was a better game, the OP has pretty bad reasons IMO. First off, saying that IGN gave Skyrim a 9.5 and SS a 10 is the worst way to defend an argument. Every single critical review of a game is biased, no matter how much or big the bias, it has bias.
Also, nothing in this world is perfect. So therefore no game deserves a perfect score. Skyrim gets glitchy at times, and SS motion controls are somewhat buggy as well. Those are two facts which I can think of off the top of my head that make Skyward Sword and Skyrim not perfect.
Last but not least, saying that Skyward Sword won best Wii game, best Zelda game, etc. isn't that hard of a challenge to overcome. TBH there aren't that many good Wii games, and the last few Zelda games IMO were pretty pathetic. If you want to say that SS is better than Skyrim because it won those awards, I can simply say that Skyrim is better than Skyward Sword because it won video game of the year for 2011. Both arguments are flawed, but atleast with video game of the year SS had a chance to win that.
Not to mention that asking this question is pointless because your asking it on a Zelda forum lol? You're obviously going to see the majority say SS, but like I said before, the two can't be compared. Each game is completley different, therefore it requires different criteria to be judged.
Last thing, this post isn't ment to bash anybody lol. I'm just stating my opinion on why these two games can't be compared
.