JuicieJ
SHOW ME YA MOVES!
I'm actually getting at why he would be their ruler after TP. FSA would take place hundreds of years after OoT's CT ending, right? If so, OoT's Ganondorf shouldn't be the Gerudo's leader/guardian, and a new Gerudo male would be (specifically, one that was born less than 100 years ago).
This is one of the things that prevents the FSS from being accurately placed anywhere on the "timeline". There's much more to it, it's not important right now. What I would like to know is why, if he's different, why he's so much like the previous Gerudo King. I mean, this isn't like with Link and Zelda where they're reincarnated to stop the evil about to rise. This is just a new king thing. I highly doubt Ganondorf would be reincarnated, as there's no reason for him to be, unlike with Link and Zelda. And why have him named the same? That just seems pointless if he's someone new.
Ah, but that's where FSA actually gives us an explanation. The Gerudo only dislike him because of breaking their laws recently (leaving to the pyramid, to be specific). Which would imply that he hadn't done anything bad until the day he left for the trident, which wouldn't match OoT Ganondorf...
What? Are you serious? The Gerudo didn't mind him trying to take over Hyrule ("doing something bad") because they're evil, as well. They're thieves. They followed him, calling him the Great Ganondorf. They didn't care what Ganondorf did to a different people (yes, that's correct English). But when he broke one of their laws, that's a completely different story.
Actually, no one was expecting Ganondorf in FSA. Nobody knew about his intentions until you actually get to the room where the trident should be. If it's dangerous for him to get the trident, it would be equally as dangerous for him to try getting the trident as he would have had a reputation for trying to obtain power.
Of course no one was. He'd been chased out. Who would have expected him to go and get the Trident? Especially when it's a secret thing that only the Gerudo knew about? That argument doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
I actually went through the thread I mentioned before and must've missed your arguments against. What are some holes with FSA being a separate Ganondorf?
If you didn't go back to The Multiple Deaths of Ganondorf!, then I probably didn't have any arguments in it. But if it was, my arguments are all over that thread. They're impossible to miss, especially since I was talking to you half the time.[/QUOTE]