Sonic is good in 2D. Always has been and always will be. Sonic Mania will be better than Sonic 2017, just like Sonic & Knuckles is better than any 3D sonic game ever (so is Sonic 3).
Sonic in 3D just doesnt work. Somehow, no matter how hard they try (Sonic Adventure), no matter how many gimmicks they use (Sonic the Black Knight/Unleashed etc) or how hard they rip off other games (Sonic Lost World), Sega just cant get Sonic in 3d to work. At all.
For a while i just thought it was all Sega's fault. I just assumed they were incapable of making good 3D games, Sonic or not.
But that's not the case. Sega made Valkyria Chronicles, a masterpiece of the genre, they helped make F-Zero GX which is frikking awesome. They make the Hatsune Diva games which lead the genre... they can make great games...
So how cant they make a good Sonic game? And by good i mean actually good, not 'good by Sonic standards' (Colours) or half good (Generations) but actually good, like Mario good.
What is it with Sonic? Or is it still Sega? Are they so clueless about their own mascot in 3D that theyre incapable of making a good Sonic game?
What do you all think, is Sega bad or is Sonic just a lost cause?
Sonic in 3D just doesnt work. Somehow, no matter how hard they try (Sonic Adventure), no matter how many gimmicks they use (Sonic the Black Knight/Unleashed etc) or how hard they rip off other games (Sonic Lost World), Sega just cant get Sonic in 3d to work. At all.
For a while i just thought it was all Sega's fault. I just assumed they were incapable of making good 3D games, Sonic or not.
But that's not the case. Sega made Valkyria Chronicles, a masterpiece of the genre, they helped make F-Zero GX which is frikking awesome. They make the Hatsune Diva games which lead the genre... they can make great games...
So how cant they make a good Sonic game? And by good i mean actually good, not 'good by Sonic standards' (Colours) or half good (Generations) but actually good, like Mario good.
What is it with Sonic? Or is it still Sega? Are they so clueless about their own mascot in 3D that theyre incapable of making a good Sonic game?
What do you all think, is Sega bad or is Sonic just a lost cause?