Guild Wars (Game Thread! Finally!)

[Kirino]

@DracoMajora
I think you'll have to go find it yourself. We don't want to clog up the thread. Part of being a good player is being able to do the research. Maybe you could take notes if you're having trouble keeping track.

Sure.How do put multiple quotes from multiple people in you're post?I've seen it done all the time(an expmle is where you voted for SW).

 

[kokirion]

Maybe that's true but there were arguments she've said you didn't mention when you was accusing SW, and why do you think that I am in a guild together with Dracomajora and SW?? Your arguments doesn't make any sense

 

[Kirino]

Maybe that's true but there were arguments she've said you didn't mention when you was accusing SW, and why do you think that I am in a guild together with Dracomajora and SW?? Your arguments doesn't make any sense

He didn't say anything about me.And he explains why in his post.

 

[kokirion]

Originally Posted by kokirion
[...]I understand why you choosed him but that was just because the game was just started...[...]



It sounds like he's picking and choosing when to use this logic. It kinds seems like he is defending a fellow guild member.
I know it sounds like I'm going after him just because he voted for me, but that is not the case.
FOS: Kokirion

this "him" in my post was you

 

[TheGreen]

I am just stating that since I haven't seen anyone else that I feel sufficently suspicious, I'm just going to hold with the vote I did during the RVS..

I don't know.. he doesn't seem very suspicious to me, I understand why you choosed him but that was just because the game was just started... People also thought I was suspicious after my first post, but if the game just started you are often saying stupid things because you're glad the game finally started and you just want to post something

The above was your post which basically said "It's silly to keep your RandomVote."
Meanwhile, you are still clutching to yours. I'm not telling you to unvote me, I'm pointing out to my fellow townies that you're picking and choosing when to use your own logic as if you're trying to defend a fellow guild member.
I was quite clear in my original analysis.

EBWODP "him" was dracomajora. You were telling Rishian that you understood why he voted for him.

 

[Elfen]

Hmm the green you seem a little to anxious dont you?? and SW im sorry but he has put many good points

 

[kokirion]

Your vote wasn't random, because you taught you had evidence, mine is something different

and what do you want?? do you really think I am a scum or is this just your revenge because I've voted for you??

 

[TheGreen]

I know it sounds like I'm going after him just because he voted for me, but that is not the case.

I would appreciate it if you read my post.

 

[kokirion]

I've already read that, but I'm not sure about it

 

[SheikahWarrior]

........

I'm getting kinda suspicious of you, TheGreen, why so suspicious of so many people <.<

FoS: TheGreen

 

[Kirino]

I'm suspicious of several people whom I will tell you about now.

I don't recall jebus voting for me in the first place, but whatever. IGMEOY: Jebus
Hmm. Well your reasons can't be that you know someone's role, unless you're a guild member. I can't imagine why you wouldn't want other people to vote the same way you do. If you had a role as one of us villagers then you wouldn't know anything that we don't already know. This leads me to believe you are in a guild, or at least want us to think you're in a guild. IGMEOY: Cel-Shaded Deku


to that I say:

Please don't get us villagers killed with your faulty math.


I find it pretty suspicious that even though He has legitimate concerns about several people he still uses a RandomVote.
He even says this to Rishian because Rishian was hanging on to his RVS way back on page six only 24 hours (real time) into the game, whereas his rvs stands

It sounds like he's picking and choosing when to use this logic. It kinds seems like he is defending a fellow guild member.
I know it sounds like I'm going after him just because he voted for me, but that is not the case.
FOS: Kokirion

Now,
Vote: ShiekahWarrior Here's why:

and

He was the only person to vote for both dead villagers.
Logic would tell you that he's either really or more plausibly a guild member who knew he wasn't voting for people in his guild.

Also he pulls this maneuver:


The way he just drops his “suspicion” right way and sides with Kokirion makes me think that they're working together, and maybe SW slipped up here. The response is too quick to ignore.

Also:

I don't even know the motive behind this. Maybe I'm looking too deep into it?
Either way its fishy and does nothing to alleviate my suspicions.

EBWODP
I meant to say "really *unlucky*" implying that the chances of making two similar mistakes are similar to your chances of winning the lottery, so ya I think he's in a guild.

He's a bit suspicious I think.

Rishian, After I had post a few things I was looking if someone else was posting here and I saw you (yesterday) other people pm'ing, I tought that was a bit suspicious and later I saw you do it again.. were you pm'ing other guild members about things in the game??

IGMEOY: @lex MM
FoS: Rishian

IGMEOY: Josie because she is no ordinary townie. She is either a scum or special townie and Cel-Shaded Deku seems suspicious for just accusing someone.

This seems pretty suspicious.First of all,you're not bringing up the posts where she did that.Also,she's just defending herself like everyone else.She doesn't seem desperate at all.That's not very good evidence.And it's not much either.She's also been proved to be a townie too.The way I see it,you are a Guild Member,who randomly threw out a weak suspicion to get an innocent Villager lynched.Though I'm not voting yet.Voting on only one piece of evidence is never a good idea.I'll wait and see your response.

FoS:OW
​

So we have @lexMM,Rishian,SW,CSD,Josie,and OW.I hope I didnt miss any.

@ kok. I was actually pm'ing Din, because my phone has been acting up and I couldn't get a hold of her before I was headed to her house.
I understand why that would be suspicious, but I would've hoped that there would be more evidence against me prior to a FOS then that.

Is that really the only reason people are suspicious of him?Really?I'll have to take him off my list then.

@lexMM,SW,CDS,OW,Josie.

And no,I didn't just edit that.ZD should really get this fixed.

 

[Rishian]

Thank you DracoMajoria for taking me off your list. I was actually sad that people used that as the best reason to vote for me.. or do a FOS on me.
I've been watching and there are a couple people that are kinda actually making me feel really anxious..

FOS on both:
Kokirion
-and-
TheGreen

I hope that I am wrong... but both of you are battling back and forth with only semi-logical responses... thus it feels like your both scum.. :S

 

[Kirino]

To me the most suspicious are SW and OW.Also,when was the last time OW posted?If i'm correct,he only posted once or twice on this thread.Seems like he's trying to lay low,a very common Mafia tactic.More the reason to be suspicious of him.My evaluation of him:He's a Guild member,who's trying to lay low,and jumped on the bandwagon(another common Mafia tactic),by voting for an Townie and giving only one reason that didn't make much sense,just to get an innocent Townie lynched for his Guild.He then procedded into hiding in the shadows again,and is not responding to his accusations,and continuing to stay low so people don't notice him.And I don't think thats because he's busy in real life,cause I saw him on twice after posting my accusations.He could still be a Townie,but i'm pretty suspicious of him.I'm still waiting to see his defense.

 

[Rishian]

*Leans back in his chair up against the wall, looking over everyones faces*

Well... we know that there are 8 guild members in this room. 4 from each guild right?

I think that OW needs to let us know why they are not scum. Hiding from peoples accusations is not the way to show innocence.
I was accused, and proved that I had good reason for what I was doing, and thus was cleared by some.

(Hey THP, could we have another listing of who has been voted for so that I can see sometime in the next day. Thanks! Sorry... I'm not very good at keeping track sometimes... :S )

 

[Hero of Time]

I too would like to see a list of votes and allow those voted on to try to argue their accusations so we can narrow it down to those that actually might be scum.