Game Thread Guess Your Role: Poke Ball Z Mafia (BMGf/ZD Crossover Event) Endgame: TBA, Town and Survivor Win! (11/7/19)

[Morbid Minish]

I mean godfather is a thing too

Yeah, but you still will never be sure of his alignment if that's the case. What do you expect him to do, claim godfather when someone asks if he's town? If Max is gonna out his result literally right after day end when nothing has changed regarding Deku, why wouldn't he do it when people were discussing a serious wagon on him?

 

[Max1996ZD]

Someone, who doesn't know he's a cop, accidentally copping the godfather, on their first attempt. Really, what are the odds?

1/18 x 1/17, I guess?

 

[Max1996ZD]

And yet you ran to Other ME’s defense when a wagon started building on him...

Exactly what I said there and nothing more.

 

[funnier6]

Yeah, but you still will never be sure of his alignment if that's the case. What do you expect him to do, claim godfather when someone asks if he's town? If Max is gonna out his result literally right after day end when nothing has changed regarding Deku, why wouldn't he do it when people were discussing a serious wagon on him?

Are you doubting the claimed cop? o-o

 

[Max1996ZD]

I'll keep ExLight and Rubik in mind. Their votes on Tristan feel the most sheep-y.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Exactly what I said there and nothing more.

The point being, you had a town check on someone against whom a wagon was building, and you did nothing.
Yes, GF is a thing, but if you spend too much time worrying about GFand rely too much on just your role, you won’t get anything done.

Meanwhile, a bandwagon starts to form on someone about whom you have zero data, and you jump in to interject.

Also, your target for tonight should be pretty damn obvious, if I say so myself.

 

[Max1996ZD]

The point being, you had a town check on someone against whom a wagon was building, and you did nothing.
Yes, GF is a thing, but if you spend too much time worrying about GFand rely too much on just your role, you won’t get anything done.

Meanwhile, a bandwagon starts to form on someone about whom you have zero data, and you jump in to interject.

Also, your target for tonight should be pretty damn obvious, if I say so myself.

I already know who I'm targeting.

 

[ExLight]

I'll keep ExLight and Rubik in mind. Their votes on Tristan feel the most sheep-y.

Right, a vote that lasted less than an hour just to extract information.
Completely sheepy unlike yours.

 

[Morbid Minish]

Are you doubting the claimed cop? o-o

No, I'm saying outing himself now instead of not letting people waste time thinking of lynching Deku was not a great move. He should have either said something then or waited so he wasn't outed so early.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

I already know who I'm targeting.

If it isn’t ME, you’re being silly.
Just saying.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Things are transpiring

 

[Max1996ZD]

Right, a vote that lasted less than an hour just to extract information.
Completely sheepy unlike yours.

Just because I usually do it doesn't mean it can't be considered scummy if someone else does it.

 

[Spiritual Mask Salesman]

Pretty much, if Max doesn't die we know he fakeclaimed for some reason. Probably to out the real cop or something.

 

[ExLight]

Are you telling me you only used your first role guess NOW? Why would you avoid sending a role guess during the entire first cycle but send an alignment guess D1?

SMS' entire role PM was revealed when his action went through because it clearly revealed his role.
If you received a message confirming that Deku is Town I can't literally think of ANY roles other than cop that can give you this kind of report.
Which makes no sense for you to say that "think you know what your role is". Why weren't you sure? Why didn't you receive your role PM?

Not to mention the message you sent before telling you were going to target Deku, what the **** was the point of that if you had no clue about your role? What if he got killed? It's pretty obvious you had some feint idea of what was going to happen.
If anything, I dare to theorize that it was a message to scum so they they didn't target Deku with a role while searching for recruitees, since the only thing you knew about you was your alignment.

You still haven't replied to those, Max.
Care to explain a few things?

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Pretty much, if Max doesn't die we know he fakeclaimed for some reason. Probably to out the real cop or something.

Unless he was protected...