Game Thread Cryptid Mafia

[Morbid Minish]

My issue is that it was a super obvious soft, and there was no reason for it. Vanilla is an easy claim for mafia in this game, and if you are actually town claiming vanilla so early for no reason just makes it easier for mafia to hit a power role.

Also, he suspected Storm for the exact same thing he did.

 

[Morbid Minish]

@The Sun Fan what were your thoughts on FG again?

 

[The Sun Fan]

the mod did say that multiple of the same role can exist so like this isn't damning
I did expect SMS to talk about how its weird that he and Giri shared the same role after he saw Giri's flip

I don't want to lynch the top poster but I guess I'll lynch the top poster
unvote
vote: SMS

 

[The Sun Fan]

@The Sun Fan what were your thoughts on FG again?

I dunno
Moe is kind of right that her re-entrance pinged a little wolfy to me but I haven't really hard a solid scumread all game
I could vote her today due to an absence of a townread and the fact that I really don't like how she got a townread on Moe for basically no reason

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

the mod did say that multiple of the same role can exist so like this isn't damning
I did expect SMS to talk about how its weird that he and Giri shared the same role after he saw Giri's flip

I don't want to lynch the top poster but I guess I'll lynch the top poster
unvote
vote: SMS

we both passed him just chilling

 

[The Sun Fan]

somehow, I still am not calling her scummy?
idk why I'm not doing that really
maybe I should be doing that

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

I really don't like how she got a townread on Moe for basically no reason

and then walked it back like it didn't exist

 

[The Sun Fan]

we both passed him just chilling

oh wow would you look at that
its still probably not the brightest idea given this game has had a dearth of activity but w/e

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

I agree that lynching top poster is usually a bad idea

smile

 

[Morbid Minish]

I dunno
Moe is kind of right that her re-entrance pinged a little wolfy to me but I haven't really hard a solid scumread all game
I could vote her today due to an absence of a townread and the fact that I really don't like how she got a townread on Moe for basically no reason

Hmm.
I'm kinda thinking of going that direction today. I know I just laid out a case on SMS, and I do still think he's scummy. But the fact SMS claimed vanilla that early is something I'm unsure scum SMS does. I definitely think he can do it out of nowhere as scum, but moreso when people have actually started suspecting people.

I feel like an FG flip could help with figuring out you/Moe a little more.

 

[The Sun Fan]

and then walked it back like it didn't exist

I went back and reread that
...
I really, really don't know what to make of that, so I'll just call it scummy, I guess?

 

[Morbid Minish]

How the **** is it still only d2?

Unvote

Vote: FG

 

[The Sun Fan]

do you disagree?

nah, its fair
just gotta

 

[The Sun Fan]

I think I'm going to hold on SMS for the time being Minish
I get why you think the Vanilla claim is not super within his range (though I am no master of SMS's range) as a wolf, but I think I prefer this one

I will switch if there appears to be a tie

I think that having a counter would be a pretty good idea here probably

 

[Mikey the Moblin]

the problem with lynching funnygurl over SMS is the question mark factor
I personally don't think my opinion on SMS will ever change and we already know that we're not at risk of losing a strong town PR with this lynch
no such luck with FG, a few more days with her can definitely make it easier to read her slot confidently