This This This. When you state an opinion it's good town play to give as many reasons for that opinion as you can. Town benefits the most from information and only in 5% of cases concerning roles is keeping opinions to yourself worth it. You hurt town by just making statments with no additional thoughts.
There is a reason your host has to ban us stating certain things: when town knows more they win easier. Don't hold back what we are allowed to say, that really is just being lazy at best and no funnier I don't care if you think it's not relevant that's for the thread to ultimately decide. If it influences your read then post it.
There's a bit of this post nested in a quote chain of replies about Stratego here I think I should respond to a bit (you can read it by clicking the link).
Good scum will quickly lay the foundations for developing a strong town rapport to make it harder to lynch them. Your early D1 interactions with sun read to me, at the time, like you were trying to lay down false town/town interactions with him so that you'd look good later in the game.
There are a lot of innocuous statements that a player can make that can seed the idea that they're town into the minds of players subconsciously and I felt like you were doing that at the time. I don't think that's a realistic possibility now unless sms flips red, in which case I'd have to revisit my original opinion.
I know you want specific examples of things you said or things other players have said that ping me, but it's not really something I like to break down too much. An example of something that might be a scum tell for me is "_ is scum or I'll eat my hat." It's a post that gets caught up in the mindset of a townie who is self-assured, but it's easily replicated by decently good scum to feign the appearance of genuine town. There are a lot of posts that people also like to slip in as scum that they can look back at the end of game and laugh at, I recall one such post from sun in Anime 2 that I latched on to during the game as a scum tell but I can't quote because ISOing that thread is broken.
I hope this explains my mindset a bit better.
I'm not super familiar with your play (we shared like a single game) and you were giving me vibes that remind me of sun's scum play with some of your posts and that was why I was scum reading you early D1. It's decently likely it was a false flag, so I'm sorry for tunneling as much as I did on the read.