By the way Kybyrian, it would help if you explained more in-depth why you are suspicious and voting for of Axle, as well as you MK9, Meego you too.
I'll sure try. I'm not one for making big analyses, though, so don't expect it to be the best.
This will probably be a mix of me defending myself against Axle posts over again and trying to get a point across, I guess.
Axle the Beast said:
Yes, you are too smart to do that as a Mafioso, and I doubt you are, but it's still obstructive to the town and weird activity for you while playing Mafia in general.
Axle's post in reference to my behavior very early in the game. He saw linksbro as more of a threat, but he continues to push towards me, though he doubts that I'm a Mafioso? Also, he references my general behavior for Mafia. This is obviously based on 1 game. The only game that I was in that I lasted for more than one day was in Mafia Round 2, in which I was godfather. He tries to explain that my behavior is weird compared to my normal behavior, which the behavior I use when I'm Mafia... yeah.
You say that, yes. It doesn't change the fact that your behavior was weird and suspicious and your statements do nothing to disprove that.
Pushing at me again... even though he stated that he believes that I wasn't Mafioso? I didn't do anything else to make myself seem even more suspicious afterwards...
Most of this game involves killing innocents, and sometimes they were as detrimental to the town as townies as they would have been as Mafia.
I understand how some townies can be detrimental to the town, but does that really mean that instead of hunting for Mafia we should go and kill them? They aren't detrimental if you care enough to ignore them... especially when you seem to know so well that they are detrimental
townies and not Mafia...
Players like linksbro, there is no way whatsoever to read their behavior, and they have as much chance to be Mafia as any other. They are wildcards. Again, I don't think he is Mafia but I can't be sure and I think he's just as dangerous as a townie.
He thinks he isn't Mafia, but he claims that he's dangerous even as a townie. Refer to my response to the quote above.
How can you honestly see these quotes and say this player is going to be able to contribute anything this game? Especially those last two, but even in the first two we have him automatically accusing his accuser without really giving any reason (which I DID give). He also asks us to tell him how to play, and I've constantly said to think for yourself. If he doesn't, he's going to be influenced by the Mafia.
Furthermore, even going with the idea that he's another townie as a buffer for later in the game, that's still another inexperienced townie who will likely put his vote on the wrong person or be controlled by the Mafia.
We have nothing to gain by leaving him alive and there are many factors he presents which can prove detrimental to us. My vote still stands as does my recommendation for others to follow suit.
He likes to focus on one person, doesn't he? He is extremely convinced that linksbro is a townie, but he's also a dangerous townie. It would seem, though, instead of keeping an open mind to the other players he simply wants to focus on linksbro. Easy to do if you know the roles of everybody, right? Who needs to pay attention when you have all that information available at your fingertips?
To be honest with some of the evidence Keyshe's posted, I'm started to not be so sure he might be townie, which only strengthens the advantages of lynching him (which was already a win-win situation). As for being suspicious of me, then good. Frankly you all should be suspicious of everyone, especially the skilled players, from the start of the game.
Now claiming that he
could be Mafia. More so than he believed before, at least, which wasn't much. He also claims that lynching him if he was a townie was a winning situation... how nice.
And yes, you have contributed to, and even though I don't think you're necessarily Mafia, you've shown yourself to be dangerous as well by pushing baseless accusation and seeding chaos. Even worse than Linksbro, to be honest. I just want him dead since he already has more votes.
I just want him dead since he already has more votes.
Perfect logic!
He also claims that he believes Jo isn't Mafia, but fears that she is dangerous. Do I see a pattern? I think I do!
I mentioned Sasuke's weirdness lightly before you did, before anyone did. Why would I do that if I was Mafia?
In his giant post against Jo, he said this. I don't know... why would you do that if you were Mafia? Maybe to make people think you weren't Mafia by mentioning his weirdness
lightly, but not enough to stir anything?
If she's not Mafia then she is clearly intentionally causing chaos by ignoring posts and seeding baseless accusations.
Finding you more suspicious than Jo, I don't believe her accusations were with a base at all. You also seem to love voting for people and then stating that they might not be Mafia, don't you? Quite a trend.
I did, actually. I said that I didn't believe linksbro was Mafia at all, but even as a Townie he was hurting the town badly, and it's been proven by how distracted this thread was when he was alive. We were talking about him constantly. Either way, by the end of the day I actually was doubting my own statement of him being innocent and actually thought he could go either way.
Once again confirming that he believed that linksbro wasn't Mafia at all yet decided to vote for him, seemingly uncaring that he was a townie... it wouldn't have been so bad if he would have kept his eyes open to watch for more potential Mafia, but it's kind of obvious that he was just focusing on linksbro.
Furthermore, would I be stupid enough as a Mafia to rally people that openly? Wasn't I virtually invisible during Group Mafia on LoZ?
Can I get an M? Can I get a K? Can I get a 9? What's that spell? MK9! Also known as virtually the best mafia player in Mafia Round 2. His actions were similar to yours and he was Mafia, and was also hardly caught.
Kybyrian and Master Kokiri 9 are two of our most skilled players.
Tanks
If it's in-character for her, fine, but it's still disruptive.
Once again Axle wants to lynch somebody even though he's acknowledging that she could be townie. He clearly says that he doesn't know if it's in-character for her, and he has people telling him that it is in-character, so why does he continue to insist that she should be lynched? He views her as disruptive, so he is basically saying, "Hey, if she's a townie, I want her gone anyway because she's disruptive." I wonder how this sounds familiar... oh yeah! Same reason for pushing on everybody he's been suspicious of. He keeps trying to get people killed who he says could be townie while not keeping an open eye for
Mafia, our goal. He's obviously more concerned with getting rid of disruptive townies than pointing out Mafia
at all. OH THE HUMANITY!
