• Welcome to ZD Forums! You must create an account and log in to see and participate in the Shoutbox chat on this main index page.

Do you have problem with characters that don't age?

GrooseIsLoose

Slickest pompadour in town
ZD Legend
Joined
Aug 16, 2019
Location
Skyloft
For example, Ash Ketchum from Pokémon franchise.

For me, I grew up with Diary of a Wimpy Kid since high school. But now, I can't imagine being a kid that reads 20 ass books with 4 year holidays with the mc still bein in high school.

I also grew up with Alex Rider and I'm happy that the author decided to age the character as well and stop the series at some point
 

Bowsette Plus-Ultra

wah
ZD Legend
Joined
Mar 23, 2013
Location
Iowa
Gender
Lizard
Yes. In something like Pokemon where Ash seems to visibly de-age as the franchise goes on then it bothers me. It definitely takes me out of the moment if a child characters spend multiple years staying super young or not adjusting their behavior at all.

In something like Resident Evil it can be super egregious. In the upcoming Resident Evil movie we're seeing the return of multiple characters who should all be in their forties and fifties. All the male characters have been aged up appropriately, but all the returning female characters look like they're fresh out of college. That sort of thing does nickle my pickle.
 

Dizzi

magical internet cat....
ZD Legend
Joined
Jun 22, 2016
If theres like an explanation like oh the guys immortal cant age then its ok but otherwise its so awkwards...
 

Ragnarokio

AVATAR NOT BY JIMMU
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Gender
If you don't identify as the default options of Male/Female, you may enter your gender here.
i don't mind it although i'm particularly fond of stories where the characters age

for better or for worse is pretty neat
 
Joined
Apr 20, 2023
Gender
Male
A character growing older is a good way to bring changes and show the passing of time, though stories can be told over the course of years or just days.

Metroid is one example in which all the adventures of Samus are only days or weeks long at the most and weeks or months apart.
So, Samus doesn't age, or seem to age.

But if a character keeps growing older, then they will eventually become too old to be the protagonist? Then they will need to retire, or if they were immortal, then the character doesn't age at all.
 

mαrkαsscoρ

Mr. SidleInYourDMs
ZD Champion
Joined
May 5, 2012
Location
American Wasteland
yeah I kinda do, I know some shows want to maintain a status quo, but it can irk me when clearly at least a year should've passed by but the characters are the same age

reminds me of something I thought of as a kid where technically Fairly Odd Parents should've had 3 years pass b/c they either show summer happening or the last day of school happen 3 times (Timvisible, Shelf Life, School's Out Musical), but NOPE, he's still in 5th grade, and this show literally had a special about Timmy wanting to stay the same age forever like on tv so he can keep his fairies
 
Joined
Apr 20, 2023
Gender
Male
Well, there's Ash. 1200 or so episodes and he's still 10 years old.
I was thinking what differences would there be if he actually did age? But I suppose keeping him 10 is keeping the series that age, too.
Young kids may not have an interest in a protagonist older than they are.

Still it would have been nice if Ash did age. 11 for Orange Islands, 12 for Johto, 13 for Hoenn, 14 for Sinnoh, 15 for Unova, 16 for Kalos and 17 for Alola.
 

Uwu_Oocoo2

Joy is in video games and colored pencils
ZD Legend
Forum Volunteer
I think if your show has some obvious sign of time passing you need to age your characters. You can only have so many Christmas specials before it gets strange, y'know? If there's no concept of how much time there is between episodes it's fine to ignore it. That's a problem I think Phineas and Ferb had, which is that they established the timeframe the show takes place in but after episode 104 it just doesn't work anymore.
 
I think that media should definitely age characters after a certain time span. If too many things happen in a small time frame like days, weeks, or months, things become unrealistic. I think this is especially a problem from action shows because nonstop action arcs don't make sense unless it's a prolonged large scale conflict like a war. Slice of life media is definitely the type that can most drag out characters being the same age because we presumably see their daily life on a daily basis.
 
Joined
Mar 20, 2023
Location
Canada
Gender
Gender-fluid (she/he pronouns)
"Do you have a problem with characters that don't age?"

Yes, yes I freaking do, and I'm far from the only one. That's why a lot of people, myself included are happy that the people behind the Pokemon anime finally got rid of Ash Ketchum and replaced him with new protags in the new Scarlet and Violet Pokemon anime. Characters that don't age are boring, undergo very little to no character development (especially if they are still 10 after like over 20 years), lose more often than not, could easily be replace with the original book protags or original video game protags who are far better and more interesting than them. The Digimon anime is infinitely better than the Pokemon anime, it has new protags every season, its protags age and pass down the torch to a new set of protags and if they stick around to help the new protags once in a while they do not take the spotlight away from the new protag or overshadow them and they defeat a ton of bad guys in the long run (Red the protag of the original first gen Pokemon video game and the Digimon cartoon protags have defeat loads of bad guys whereas Ash Ketchum couldn't even defeat Team Rocket and never even face its boss and Red defeated Team Rocket single-handedly including their boss before passing down the torch to Gold).

A lot of people, myself included, are glad that Ash-Loser-Ketchum has finally been retired, a lot of the video game protags would make far better protags for the anime than the eternally 10-years-old, perpetually devoid of any character development and maturing, perpetually friendzoned, lost every league except one on accident after 17 years Ash Ketchum:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLzG_3q50DuPmhYi24aFWKothJ5qe5wAvn

This is why I much prefer the fanfictions, the ones that don't have Ash in it, the ones with the video game protags, the ones where the characters age or are aged-up, get real jobs, go on dates/get married (have some kind of love life unlike the 10 year-old loser Ash who never grow up and never go on an actual date, there's one tiny little kiss on the mouth between him and Serena but they censored it and we weren't allowed to see much of it then she left forever and he never saw her again, he never grew uo and never had an actual love interest), have kids, teach their kids good values and support their's kids goals and dreams, help train the next generation of trainers, maybe go on a journey or a quest with a friend or loved one to learn more about themselves and the world, etc.

This looks better than the lame Ash anime, so let's hope that those new protags will be allowed to age and that there will be new ones every new season (this is why so many prefered the Digimon anime over the Pokemon anime, the Digimon is ever-changing and always refreshing whereas the Pokemon anime had perpetually unaging loser kid for a protag, never had new protags every new season, and had a sore loser protag who just kept sticking around instead of passing down the torch to the next generation):



We'll see where Horizons will lead...

The only characters that I'm okay with them not aging (and those characters are NOT human) are characters who are IMMORTAL amd were created to be IMMORTAL from the beginning, like an angel or a demon or some similar immortal spirit being/supernatural being (like the angel Aziraphale and the demon Crowley from "Good Omens" who look like adults and look like they're in their late forties to early fifties anyway) because they were never meant to age and never aging is one of the characteristics of their SPECIES, not only do these beings not age, but some of them can also sometimes shape-shift and appear any age they want. Though it's just a physical appearance or a supernaturally made corporation and they are not actually that age. 'Cause some of those beings are MILLIONS OF YEARS OLD CELESTIALS AND PREDATE CREATION ITSELF, like Aziraphale and Crowley.

As Dizzi said:

"If there's like an explanation like, "the guy is IMMORTAL and can't age" then its ok but otherwise its so awkwards..."

And as bowsette said:

"Yes. In something like Pokemon where Ash seems to visibly de-age as the franchise goes on then it bothers me. It definitely takes me out of the moment if a child characters spend multiple years staying super young or not adjusting their behavior at all."

And zettafleya is wrong about young kids may not have an interest in a protagonist older than they are, a lot of them want to see the protags age and grow up with them, a lot of kids left the Pokemon anime when they reached 12 or 13 because age didn't age and didn't go on dates and didn't show any sign or growing up and maturing with its audience of kids. Those kids much prefer the manga and the fanfics.

And as this guy pointed out, no little kid truly wants to be like Ash Ketchum and they are better than him because they evole their Pokemon and want the strongest, and most badass Pokemon (unike Ash and is rookie team of garbage mons) and they can defeat several leagues single-handedly in the video games whereas Ash lost all of the leagues he faced in the anime save one he won on accident after 17 years, Noble Absinthe is telling it like it is:

 
Last edited:

TheGreatCthulhu

Composer of the Night.
Joined
Jan 22, 2016
Location
United States of America
Gender
Very much a dude.
Yes, I do generally have a problem with it, especially considering that age can give a different perspective to a character, both in how the audience views them, and the character's own perspective.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom