This character list crap is pointless. Just saying.
Mido I agree with you on PatCat. That post is extremely uncomfortable.
Vote: PatCat
Wow I didn't realize this was the first post made by Jamie which is actually something that makes me really uncomfortable but also a little more ok with him. It's slightly ok because he at least recognized we were taking a bit more serious approach to day one. BUt here we also see him just agree on Mido and then vote.
I didn't even know Johnny was voting for you. I just thought your post was weird as hell.
This is where he contradicts himself on the previous post. There is no way Jamie could have read, and found patcat's post uncomfortable, without also knowing Johnny had voted when Patcat clearly stated "Looks like Johnny voted for me" in the post Jamie found questionable. Seems like Jamie may not be reading everything in posts.
I usually vote instead of FoS. Not trying to achieve a lynch, but it's nice to see how people react under pressure. I don't think I'm taking my vote off right now though.
Fair enough, pressure voting is a thing.
This logic makes no sense... One, I said it was for pressure because it's good to see how people react. Two, I didn't even know Johnny had started it. Three, how is Mido on a "wagon" when he was the second person to vote? Four, we don't even know Pat's alignment. Five, it's ****ing day one lol.
One, I said I didn't think you had explained your vote and I was wrong. Two, because you aren't reading. Three, Mido started a wagon. Even though he was second to vote the first vote on patcat was rvs vote. Four, of course we don't. Five, Lol why is this necessary. This is what I meant to respond to this with when I found you contradiction and decided to post about that instead. This post still rubs me the wrong way even now because it has way too much emotion in it for no reason.
If you don't want to start a lynch, you shouldn't contribute to a lynch. This seems like such a, once again half assed response. Keeping my vote on you.
When you made this post I was thinking the same thing someone pointed out later, what about you and your pressure vote. That's not really wanting to start a lynch, so why contribute. Honestly if you think this way you should FOS unless that isn't grabbing attention, then vote.
was just a response to pat posting the same thing 5 times. nothing strange.
i appreciate you posting this 5 times to get my attention
And ah, I didn't understand what you meant. Thought you meant you'd hop on a wagon with the current evidence, but makes more sense now.
Not really, to answer your question. We've focused a lot on minor things more or less, I find it weird how everyone is getting on all of us for joining a "wagon" (one which I did not know existed), but it seems more like a hive mind mentality than anything.
Well you were the second vote on the wagon, third on patcat and you added yours pretty quick. You helped make it become a wagon, even if it was just pressure voting.
@Ver-go-a-go-go I don't think I've been that strange this game. Last game it was more of a symptom of being busy and not really paying attention.
And it seems you aren't really paying attention this game but that's just what I'm gathering this far from rereading your posts
Would never day 1 no lynch in a game this size. just makes day 2 basically like day 1 except now we have a dead townie from a mafia kill and no leads
fair enough.
if she meant town or mafia, i dont really understand that. of course they could be either town or mafia, thats the most wishy washy post ever.
except it was pretty obvious that it was meant to be typed "scum or mafia" and I saw it more as a joke myself and not trying to state an obvious fact that someone could be town or mafia. unless we want to take Scum to mean SK and maybe we found our SK slipping but I doubt they'd do that.
Those are not mutually inclusive and are rather different situations.
You should only contribute to a lynch if you want to lynch that person...obviously. I wasn't contributing to a lynch, I was pressure voting...how are those the same thing? Aside from that, I misinterpreted PatCat and we cleared it up immediately. How is this still a thing?
It was still a thing because you were still on patcat long after pressure voting him. No matter your intent, Voting is contributing to a lynch whether you re pressure voting or not, as a vote brings them closer to dying. Even if you did not intend to lynch patcat, your vote contributed in bringing him a closer to death. This is why I feel FoS can be better unless they don't respond to FoS, which I realize goes against my own vote on Patcat as I said I was pressure voting but I also never said I wasn't contributing to a lynch. If patcat didn't post better, I would have been fine to lynch.
@Ver-go-a-go-go
I don't see why we'd lynch johnny since he was the first voter...? Hero of Legend just seems noobie to me, so I guess linkdude.. although I don't see why we'd lynch any of them..?
Johnny was also rvs so I agree there, agree, and agree. Can't sy much about this one
Jesus Christ guys lol I feel a bit offended that you think I'd have some monumental collapse on day 1...
I saw PatCats post, I swear on my life I didn't know Johnny was on any sort of wagon, maybe I was tired or something, but what stood out was just a general weird way of posting. What exactly is the big deal about being the third person on a wagon of again, an UNKNOWN ALIGNMENT on day 1? This is the weirdest attempt to lynch me in my entire mafia career that's for sure.
Sorry but isn't everyone's alignment unknown on every day? Even if we have a cop result, in a role madness game we can't be sure of alignment. What if scarlet witch targeted out cop night one and messed up the result somehow? What if we have a paranoid cop? There are many possibilities that I think prevent us from knowing an alignment even if we think we know. This post seems really odd to me.
Yes, it does, because it's day 1, I think it's good to lynch someone, and I can't see a better person to lynch atm.
Everyone else had already backed off so, why?
Fam you forgot, I don't feel pressure. But I will answer any questions you might have.
Are direct votes the only way someone can throw down suspicion? I'm not appealing to sympathy lol, I just seriously don't understand the lynch or why you think as scum I'd play like this? It wasn't about the vote it was about multiple people putting me on their scum list.
Of course I'm going to respond as quick as I can with as much defense as I can. I want to stay alive so I can win the game. I trust my scumhunting and me dying = 1. Less scumhunting and 2. No fun for me because I'm yknow, dead. I always defend myself strongly. Perhaps it's not working especially swimmingly this time but this is pretty standard from me.
You aren't doing much scum hunting, and I don't like how you just go "Why you think as scum I'd play like this" argument. It seems like a half assed defense to me. And you saying "this is pretty standard for me" I have never liked the "I play this way" argument as not everyone knows how you play all the time so are people just supposed to trust what you say about how you play?
At this point, not much. I'm open to changing my vote but not open to a no lynch. Not voting at all makes that last scenario that much more likely.
fair enough
Hmm but how much different am I in any other game?
I'll admit I haven't done much scumhunting. I don't think there's much to be done ss all of the discussion has been about a 30 second bandwagon on day 1. Knowing pats alignment would be telling, but at the same time it's hard to get a good enough read to justify a lynch (other than one just so we have /some/ info after day 1.. and a lynch requires 6 votes) because I don't think he's said very much other than "I'm not scum" something something.
LD is playing very true to his meta, he always confuses me lol but I don't see anything weird about him. Legends is new so I can't really get a read. Seems like she is just trying to scumhunt as a newbie. Johnny has done nothing suspicious. Mido was only the 2nd person on the wagon. I don't see why there necessarily has to be some on a wagon that didn't even end in a lynch.
I do hope I am not a vig target. If you want to investigate me whoever the cop is that's fine but as one of the top posters in the game thus far in terms of quantity I would really appreciate me not being a n1 vig target lol. At least allow me to scum hunt for a day or two.
Well we've given you a chance to scum hunt, lets go to day two