Search results for query: *

It'd be pretty trivial to simply use this as reasoning for why you wouldn't have lynched him, and then claim that the Mafia is clearly trying to frame you. It would probably work, too, and getting rid of the player most suspicious of you as well as the tracker would certainly be worth the risk...

I'll answer any questions, but I can't really help it if people decide to lynch me over Krow since it's essentially random, and it doesn't really matter anyway if one of us is scum. Have fun.

Since there haven't been any counterclaims (and now's the time to do so if applicable for any undeclared PRs or SK), we can assume that Pancake and Storm are telling the truth. In my original list, that leaves only Krow, although I initially had a slight town read on him for the way that Lumine...

It's worth pointing out that Doc (who Storm replaced) defended Stormageden against my suspicions of him on Day 1, which I think provides evidence for him being town. Likewise, if Storm were scum, I'm not sure what good it would do to suddenly fakeclaim tracker, claim that Moe didn't target...

I previously stated that his vote on me for bringing up no lynching gave me a slight town read on him: Besides that, basically the same reasoning as others: his actions the last day were too ridiculous and risky for me to view them as reasonably done by a Mafia member. That's essentially it...

I'm not suspicious of any of the active players. As I've said before, funnier's aggressive activity and scatterbrained/spontaneous posting style cause me to view him as town, and Moe's posting style inclines me towards a town read on him as well, largely for the same reasons, although he's...

I realize that I haven’t been very active today, by the way, so I’ll post more on Day 3. The Night period should give me adequate time to review the thread and come up with some developed reads. I wish I could dislike this post.

Just for fun: Vote: Stormageden

It's hard to tell whether Stormageden is actually bad scum trying to appear town by following the town or just a townie who's so inept that he always ends up convinced by the last thing he reads. Or an SK, as Moe seems to think. According to funnier and Doc (now Storm) on Day 1, at least, his...

Between randomly claiming as vanilla on the first day, not realizing that Gumball is dead, and now claiming Rubik as scum with no reasoning (and just being pointlessly cryptic in general), I'm really not liking Yiga's play. Even if he's not scum, it's anti-town. Vote: YIGAhim I find Funnier's...

That's mostly what I meant; they just seem spontaneous and disorganized, in a way that influences me toward a town read, since I'd expect scum to be more careful. I didn't mean any offense by it, lol. I've played plenty of games with inactive scum, including one in which the entire Mafia team...

It's hard to help being suspicious of Funnier, especially given his unvote on Yiga yesterday, but his aggressive activity, poor and haphazard wording, and seemingly genuine frustration all tempt me to read him as town. But apparently he's good enough, and this is his meta, to the point that I...

It's about that time: does anyone have any suspicions? Who should we lynch? I'll be gone until 11:00, unfortunately, so I won't be here for the end. If I have to pick someone, I guess it'll be Stormageden, since I'm very slightly suspicious of him and find his playstyle unhelpful to the town...

I don't think my action actually needed an "excuse", but I provided one anyway. It does seem like you're letting your hatred of no lynches cloud your judgement here, although I think it gives me a slight town read on you.

I'd like to note that I never actually advocated for a no lynch. Ask anyone here and they'll tell you that I've always opposed it vehemently. With that in mind, the reason I asked what others thought of it was to see who if anyone would support the idea, and then disagree with and probably...

I'm honestly glad that I'm being suspected, since at least people are talking about something. Let's assume I'm Mafia: what was I trying to do by asking people what they thought of a no lynch?

Unvote: Stormageden Vote: Fused I wasn't around last game and wasn't aware that no lynching was discussed, but yeah. Also to help get some reads because, as you said, there's a right answer.

Anyone else find it odd that Stormageden initially disagreed with Moe’s plan, then suddenly “understood” it (his post showing he clearly didn’t) after being voted by Moe, only to then suspect Moe once others posted against it? There’s also the defensive nature of his reaction to being voted...

I'm not sure that you need to have experienced an idea directly to be able to criticize it on its merits. If the criticisms made of the idea are misguided or incorrect, then you should be able to explain why and make the case for it if you want it to be implemented. Otherwise, I hope you...

Likewise. I was going to answer this, but I'm curious to see why you and others think I would. Couldn't the Mafia use this to narrow down and nightkill the PRs by seeing who has the most correct information and who has false information, especially in the case of a tracker? Seems like an...

The typical scum ratio is 1/4 or 1/5; in a game with 13 players, this amounts to 3.25 and 2.6, respectively. 2 is obviously too low (and 4 too high, since that'd make the ration nearly 1/3), so I'm assuming that there are 3 scum. Just to get some discussion going: what is everyone's opinion on...

Existing is a scumtell

your mom is a scumtell

Vote: Fused keeping the tradition alive

*dabs on the Mafia*