talking about the setup real quick, should we expect 2 mafia since SMS was a serial killer according to Tristan?
3 mafia and sk is fairly normal even for a 13 player setup on zd.
This may mean Dipper n Stan are jailed probably
@Mellow Ezlo @Johnny Sooshi @Morbid Minish what do you think?
Doubt that's what it means.
ok, yeah?
what's wrong with the timing of my vote?
Ugh, so I went back to fact check myself and the reasons for my suspicions are actually mistaken. I didn't like the fact you were the third vote when there were two other 2 vote wagons because it could've been to save one of them. But I was mistaken about when the other wagons formed (thought they were earlier than that). Also wrong on you being third vote. Because despite that being where funnier put you I found that you were actually the first. So yeah probably should've fact checked myself first instead of trying to go off final vote count.
Unvote
. As far as my statement saying scum are strong, it's a prediction. If SMS was specifically being considered an SK with what I know his powers are in terms of volume, he was seriously nerfed. That's why I believe scum are strong.
Are people forgetting roles and alignment were randed separately? So the scum team could be any mashup of roles. Therefore third party wouldn't be adjusted for balance.
for being ready to jump into the game I feel like you haven't done a lot today so far. Your read on Ex yesterday seemed opportunistic and you yourself seem to more or less agree its not a case you actually believe in. Finding faults in ex's play is easy.
I can appreciate that you weren't giving the game much attention for outside-of-game-reasons. I myself am giving this game less attention than I'd like because other games and people have been competing for my time. with that said, I'm appreciative that you did post a fairly comprehensive list of reads. What disturbs me isn't so much your lack of effort but the lukewarm-ness of your reads. I feel like in past games you'd more or less made a point of singling out one person and supporting a lynch on them, and in this game you're reading a lot of people as null or town and a couple as "maybe scum i guess". It doesn't sit well with me.
Yeah I probably got ahead of myself with the jumping into the game thing. I thought having the other game over would motivate me more here but I've been distracted quite a bit.
I did believe in my case against Ex yesterday. That's kinda why it was my most detailed read. I felt I had found something there and then he replied to it and I started having doubts. I also kinda felt bad because I feel like I always go after Ex. One thing that I mentioned was him saying he knew nothing about Gravity Falls and then him talking about the cloning machine and I felt it could've been something a scumbud told him. But then realized he did look some stuff up in MtG mafia so his claim of reading up on flavor didn't seem too farfetched to me.
The lukewarmness of my reads is fair. But that's probably more due to the fact that besides the top 3 posters everyone else had such few posts. Moe, Ex, and Sunfan are the top posters and I had a pretty decent town read of Moe. The other two were scum leans. My read of Ex was probably my most comprehensive. And while Sunfan had a lot of posts I felt he hadn't said a ton, hence the iffy read on him. I also have a pretty solid town read of you, one of the next highest posters. But everyone else just hasn't given me enough content to read them off of. And ngl, I usually bounce ideas back and forth with funnier so it's a little harder not having him in game to do that with.
It is fair that I haven't been able to stick with a scumread though and that's probably from not having my mind completely in the game. I need to start from scratch and re-read some things and see where I end up.
I do think it's a bit interesting that Johnny hinted at backup and inherited Sms's abilities even though afaik backup usually only inherits roles from their own alignment. But I guess it could be due to the fact that all roles could be town roles.
