Game Thread DW's Very Creatively Titled Mafia

[ExLight]

I would like to take a moment to point out that you literally gave scum a visitor role in your custom mafia game. RIP Jinjo.

oh yea the twins
but she had a FANCY role
splitted double wagons was definitely the highlight of it, the visitor was just because I thought it needed more stuff to it

still slightly annoyed at everyone voting her at the same twin wagon time and it never coming up properly lol

also I miss playing with her but last time she got so stressed and I think that's why she doesn't play anymore because of it

 

[OGSniper]

You’ve gotta be aggressive! D1 lynches are great.

Hmm, well, maybe. I guess they could be good if one's life wasn't on the line.

 

[JamieIsBored]

who else do you think i should be building a case on?

Whoever you think is sus. It doesn’t matter if you’re wrong.

 

[ExLight]

Vote: Killjoy262

 

[lain]

Whoever you think is sus. It doesn’t matter if you’re wrong.

exlight IG? although apparently we will know whether they're town by tomorrow, or at least someone said that?

 

[JamieIsBored]

Looking at a Killjoy vote too. Would like to wait for his views before I vote him though.

 

[JamieIsBored]

exlight IG? although apparently we will know whether they're town by tomorrow, or at least someone said that?

I said that lmao. Is it something inthread thats tipping you off? If it is could you quote it please and we can discuss.

 

[OGSniper]

Ye, Killjoy needs to state his case.

 

[lain]

I said that lmao. Is it something inthread thats tipping you off? If it is could you quote it please and we can discuss.

it kind of feels like they're trying to build an excuse on the spot why the cop thought they were mafia, and i kind of get the vibe that the way they've presented it has changed as the thread has gone on which could be like refining the excuse/lie but thats really completely vibe based i need to go back and reread if i want to be sure at all about that. also it kind of feels like they're trying too hard to defend themself.

 

[ExLight]

I just wanna play the game
of course I'll defend myself

 

[Storm]

Well if i die tomorrow, go for Exlight
Vote: Killjoy

 

[DarthCreeper10]

so why are we voting out Killjoy? Because he hasn't posted?

 

[Mint Elv]

so why are we voting out Killjoy? Because he hasn't posted?

No he’s posted to say he’s been playing a game. And Lain has pointed out some meta.

 

[Ragnarokio]

i'm still not fully caught up but why is any lynch other than exlight being seriously considered? there's some possibility ex is miller but it should be less than the possibility of him being scum by a factor of at least 2.

if we assume the game has 3 scum, one of which is a godfather, and one miller, then a red check indicates a 2/3 chance of being scum and a 1/3 chance of being miller. In practice, there might not be a miller and there might not be a godfather, which pushes the chance about 2/3 by some amount. If we think there's a 50% chance of a miller being in this game then ex has a 75% chance of being scum. the possibility of framers, multiple millers, insane cops, etc. can reduce this probability, but considering the rarity of these kinds of roles, shouldn't reduce it by much.

there shouldn't be a better alternative here, its good to discuss other cases but the lynch should ultimately end up on ex today unless something huge happened in the past 6 pages

 

[lain]

i'm still not fully caught up but why is any lynch other than exlight being seriously considered

iirc jamie was saying we'll know whether ex's claims are true by tomorrow although tbh i dont understand exactly why