• Welcome to ZD Forums! You must create an account and log in to see and participate in the Shoutbox chat on this main index page.

Game Thread Dungeons and Dragons Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 3, 2019
I think I like Minish more for that reads list; doesn't feel like mafia trying to get something out but rather a town explaining where they are @
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
oh wait eod is 6pm est so i can be here

for some reason I thought it was a 10pm eod or something

idk if yall want me to mich else though
 

Mellow Ezlo

Bumpkin
ZD Champion
Forum Volunteer
Joined
Dec 2, 2012
Location
eh?
Gender
Slothkin
Vote: ZinnLav

Boo. It's not hard to contribute, reminds me of your attitude in the hydra game.
leetic's first serious post. Getting the ball rolling with a vote on Zinn. Seems like a serious vote though and more than just a pressure vote.

I wish I could come up with a noble excuse for my inactivity, like I was busy doing some volunteer work to help the poor and that's why I have not posted much. However, the true reason for my inactivity is... I was sleeping. Come on, I just got basically all my schoolwork for the year done, I need my beauty rest!

Anyway, rainbow reads list so I have something done for the day:

Funnier6 - One of the biggest contributors. I don't like reading wallposts like that, though that is more a personal thing.
Moe the Moblin - Is playing to his town meta. I still haven't seen his scum meta, but he still is one of the biggest contributors.
Ryuken - Seems similar to his "town" (even if he was technically a survivor) play on the hydra game.
Mido - Does have a couple of decent posts that are pushing the game forward.
DekuNut - Has been contributing to the game at least, not something I typically see from his scum play.
LittleGumball - Seems to be a reactive player rather than an interactive one. Keeping a joke vote and later justifying it looks a little weird to me. However, she has at least tried harder than most of the people below her on the list, so gets some points there.
Zelda18 - Only has one post, detailing her(?) inactivity. Forgetting that the game is going on might be a town lean, as you'd expect scum to be more invested, but made an excuse for why they won't be here a while and not a particularly valid one...
Doc - Really inactive, and this one doesn't even have an excuse for why. Basically just active lurking at this point, though I suppose I'm not one to talk.
Link 182 - Hasn't done much besides screwing around, expressed distaste for the FG wagon but doesn't really explain why. Basically CWAC.
Funnygurl555 - I do have to admit, seems different from the FG I'm used to. Seems a bit tunnely and more interested in proving she's town than solving the game.
Tristan - Apparently is busy and I respect that, however their only real contributing post expressed distaste at people trying to get things done on D1. If that's the only thing you have to say, it doesn't look too good.
Morbid Minish - A lot of posts read as "could be town or scum", "I don't know how to read this person", etc., not to mention voting someone just because they're inactive. Overall very flaky and CWAC.
ZinnLav - Even if that's supposedly how they "always" play, the lack of cooperation or motivation to get anything done D1 just looks bad to me. There's a difference between not being confident in yourself but still trying, and just doing this.
Honestly, I like this early game reads list, and i appreciate leetic for being among the first people to generate serious reads. And, looking back, these reads actually look genuine and not like they're made up.

Really? That will get us nowhere if she flips town.
This was in response to a Zelda18 vote. Calling someone out for voting someone inactive just because they're inactive. Leetic shares a similar stance as me since I also disagree with lynching inactives for that reason. I like this post.

Come on, six pages were generated after I left, and ya still dropped the ball. I am not impressed.
This one could be read as either mafia trying to get in a quick word at the start of day 2 or a townie frustrated at the outcome of day 1.

Anyway, we know that Zelda is town. Since her wagon didn't get hounded at EoD, that suggests that Zinn is also town, unless there's a team of Zinn + FG/Moe + someone inactive
Based on EoD, Zinn and Zelda were likely two competing town wagons
Here, leetic gets mixed up, indicating maybe he wasn't really paying that great of attention, which Minish called out:

You're kinda climbing up there on my scum lean list. Partially because of seeming like you're not paying as close attention as town should. Partially because you seem different from the hydra game. Granted, you were paired with FG then so I don't really like trying to use that meta too much.
To be completely honest, I find leetic's mix up to be more of a town tell, since mafia should try to be as attentive as possible whereas townies aren't as afraid to miss stuff because then they don't have to come up with a defense on the spot.

Since it is causing some problems, this is the post that confused me. Due to FG's lack of punctuation, I was unsure that this was supposed to be a question, and took it as FG taking responsibilty for Zelda's death. I wasn't paying too close attention to the post after that.
More getting mixed up. I am a little confused as to how leetic missed the Mason claim since, not only was it claimed, but funnygurl was also confirmed Mason by Link 182's death. This is also leetic's last post and it was almost a whole day phase ago.

Looking back, leetic's day 1 was actually a lot better than I thought. I really like the reads list and the fact that he (she?) was among the first people to generate serious reads. The main thing I'm confused about is how he seemingly didn't notice the Mason claim when it was so obvious. I also don't like how he has disappeared completely since Monday.

I'm glad i reread leetic because i feel better about him now and don't really want to lynch him. However, his disappearance after Monday is concerning so I hope to see him soon after Day 3 starts or I'll start getting wary.

LG is next, but it'll be pretty close to EoD so my vote might stay on Ryu.
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
ok so tristan agrees that the tell is...telling.

gah, this makes me really confused. since tristan has been giving his thoughts i've been thinking he's more townie. i might keep my vote on lg then.

yo the zelda18 thing really did kill my confidence
 

Mellow Ezlo

Bumpkin
ZD Champion
Forum Volunteer
Joined
Dec 2, 2012
Location
eh?
Gender
Slothkin
Alright, I looked back through LG's posts.

I'm not going to quote them all because I'm on the bus and for the most part I'd be reiterating the same thing. I still feel like she was playing it kinda safe day one by voting for an inactive and seeming kind of... hesitant? Is that a good word? And I also noticed that she pointed out she normally doesn't like lynching inactives day 1 yet voted for one who had reasoning and left Z18 alone when she didn't have a ton of reason. Looking back, her read on me also kinda feels manufactured, but that might also just be me looking into it too much. Leetic also pointed out during day 1 that her justification for her RVS vote on me kind of came out of nowhere, which it does kind of seem that way looking back at it. It also feels like she's been tunneling me a bit.

Also during day 1, she had a sudden vote switch to Link 182 that seemed to come out of nowhere since she hadn't really talked about her beforehand, and then quickly retracted it after the Mason claim. I'm not sure what to think of that situation.

Her vote on Ryu is fine I suppose, though she didn't really explain it much, just voted after suspicion started really piling up on him. Seems a little opportunistic to me.

Not super liking LG this game, but I'm not going to tie up the votes this close to EoD. I'm fine with Ryu being lynched so I'll keep my vote where it is. I actually think a Ryu/LG scum team could be possible since this is a good bussing opportunity, but we'll see after Ryu flips.
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
yeah tristan i was going through the vc along with ryuken's case and both of them look bad but if this is busing then they have to be more strategic with it...

the more i think about it, even though the ryuken wagon an /ok/ option, i'm staying on lg. i want ryuken to come back at least
 

HeroOfTime

Challenger Approaching!
Joined
Jul 17, 2014
Location
Hyrule
Gender
Mail
Nothing's happened since Minish's VC, so I just added the two votes she missed

Current vote count:

The Sun Fan - 1 (Rubik)
Ryuken - 4 (Moe the Moblin, ZinnLav, LittleGumball, Tristan)
ZinnLav - 1 (Ryuken)
LittleGumball - 2 (The Sun Fan, Funnygurl555)
Leetic - 3 (Morbid Minish, DekuNut, Doc)

Not voting: leetic

Day ends in 20 minutes!! Last call!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Top Bottom