Do You Think a Steampunk Themed Zelda Game Would Be Good?

[fireslayr]

I cant think of anything to write here. The title says it all.

 

[triple split]

I think it would be good if it was for sheik as the main character and they made it into a platformer

 

[Draymorath]

No, Zelda is made for medieval fantasy. Steampunk just isn't what Zelda is.

 

[fireslayr]

we had trains in ST. How is that medievel

 

[Draymorath]

we had trains in ST. How is that medievel

That was one small thing in a sea of all Zelda. It was just a special thing in one of the games that made it stand out from the rest of the games. Besides, it's just one element in the game in an otherwise fantasy environment, it's not like the entire game was covered with technology like that. I would also like to add that the tracks sealed a Demon King or something like that, they weren't just there because the people are more advanced. Not sure, I haven't actually played the game. =/

 

[KirbyBBQ]

Maybe if it had a steampunk undertone,
but I don't think a full on steampunk theme would be a good idea.
I think it would take too much away from what Zelda is.

 

[Draymorath]

OHOHOHOHOH!!! I gots an idea! What if there were a steampunk-themed Dungeon!?

 

[Dio]

YES! I would love one. Set it after FSA and have them build upon TP's world.

 

[cucco002]

Zelda is not medieval only, mainly yes, but not only

I like the idea, but just if its not too extreme, similar to Spirit Tracks, the one that already seems steampunk to me, or more, why not

 

[Mugen]

steampunk is fun but in a zelda game u cant have too much of it, just small features or an area/race that is designated too it

 

[DemonPrincess]

I wouldn't mind a steampunk Zelda, but not to an extreme. Steampunk elements would be cool.

 

[SuperMetroid]

After experiencing the Lanayru Mining Facility, upon other places, I'm wholly open to the idea of steampunk themes in my Zelda. But just don't make it a Steampunk Zelda... if you know what I mean.

I don't want to see every man and their dog driving a steampowered cart/train around like those ridiculous Lokomos. I am yet to play Spirit Tracks, but I think I've seen enough.

 

[TrueChaos]

maybe the odd part but not if it was in an age of steam. wouldn't be Zelda

 

[Mivfs]

Zelda has a medieval feeling to it excluding ST and PH. I just don't think that it would fit the genre of video game that Zelda is.

 

[TwilightDeku]

Well we had trains... so we already had steam. But as for an ENTIRE game with steampunk... YES!!! I love steampunk and I am quite obsessed with it. One thing that always confused me about spirit tracks was why there weren't any guns. Trains were invented before guns... right?