Search results for query: *

Would and want are to different scenarios my dear ragamuffin. ;) I'll forever disagree with your assessment in mylo. Not because of the information principle, but because the argument can literally be applied to every other player since FG was a replacement for a completely inactive player with...

You and Rag should have. I wasn't sold on DW until Rag decided to jump FG and go for you which conveyed protecting both. Similarly I was ready to swing on Ex at the drop of a hat too and almost did when fext went over except he jumped back to Eli too quick for me to respond. My only confident...

@ExLight @Morbid Minish @KingofDominaria @EliThePsycho Rag has just given it away jumping behind Eli's KoD vote (despite saying FG was her ideal lunch behind Eli). The scum play is clearly to pile behind a seeming defunct Eli to either power out a mislynch or tie at worst case scenario. I'll...

I took some time hunting down Eli on Mafia colosseum today. Dude seems like he's just a waste of a slot in any game he's in. His remarks that he's confused are more than likely just to cover that he doesn't want to put any effort into the game, and I don't say that as an accusation. The last few...

Alrighty then. Vote: Eli

Can you expand on this more? Like what specifically aren't you comprehending? You seem like you have some sort of base of experience since you were trying to get fext to come play on another site, so a compare and contrast type post might help either us to relate with where you're coming from or...

It's a big tin foily mess. My brain wants to see a derisive DW-Ex-Eli scum team right now. But it's an extremely loaded scenario of DW distancing from Ex into disappearing, leaving Ex hanging in the wind and becoming stressed as a leading wagon day 1 off of a non essential bus until he explodes...

See min gets it.

You're looking at the EoD count. Fext moved his vote to Eli after Eli voted you. So at the time of Eli's vote he was sitting at two votes, as was KoD. So when he moved his vote from KoD to you, it changed nothing about the current state. Then Fext jumped to Eli and encouraged KoD to get back on...

Yeah I'm not seeing where you get this. His vote on you didn't really affect the game state. He was the second vote on KoD and shifted to be the second vote on you literally with 1 minute left in day. Fext still had a 2 vote lead there and there was still a competing tied wagon with his own...

Here's a question for you rag. Do you think Ex would trigger the way he did if a scum mate votes him early and dipped from the thread for a large portion heading into EoD? Add to that Ex stating numerous times he doesn't feel scum need to bus in this format.

I can see it but I wouldn't call it my favorite pairing. Eli didn't actually vote Ex until after Ex's self vote. From a scum!Eli perceiving scum!Ex position he could simply be irritated enough with the throw to pile on at that point. This results in a derisive scum chat and as history has...

Yeah?

The only person I'll entertain switching to is Minish. Do with that what you will.

It's probably be Min.

"I take it back about Numbers. Despite the resistance he's seen from me on my views, he's scum reading me. He's on the scum team." -KoD, about me the last time we were both VT and I told him his logic was jank (roughly six years ago). XD So yeah, this doesn't feel odd to me. My behavior is...

Unofficial Vote Count: Fext: 15377 Eli: KoD, Ex KoD: Fext Ex: Rag

I bolded the unvote to emphasize how much of a misread calling that post a defense was. It speaks far more to fext than KoD, imo. If FG wasn't a replacement I'd be right there with you. But replacements don't get treated like they've been here the whole game. It's poor form at the very least...

There isn't much need to read most of his post, it's mostly just him **** talking funny and Eli for nonsensical reasons. Funny is basically him hard scum reading her for saying she forgot she agreed to replace in. I don't feel like I need to elaborate more on why that's nonsensical. Eli's is a...

I'd say it was mostly likely a combination of factors double hiders (as far as I can tell from the last recap you posted Rag that was the only target with multiples, ja) and touted strength of seanzie as town. But I say that strictly from my own perspective. Everybody else should be operating...

If they believed his self hype then he called for the targeting himself. Picking a player with multiple claims also looks good from a Mafia pov because you literally increase your chances of getting the hider in a secondary kill there. states at fext Honestly I'm not surprised the hider ate it...

Y'all chose the wrong CFD and the last few pages show it. Anyways, I'm not going to try to keep up with the spamfest so I'll see y'all on the other side of deadlines. Here's some parting thoughts, @Fext Rag is right in that we want to disperse our targets as much as possible. Not only will...

@Ragnarokio I put mine down as seanzie.

Sure you can. The aim of hider cover is to allow them to lay a legacy hidden in a bunch of other fake legacies. The vanilla town changing their fake target post night doesn't stop that. Let's say you're scum and I fake a pre night claim that I'm going to hide behind you. Coming into day 2 with...

I took it to mean a post target. "I will target" vs "Last night I targeted".

You keep saying things like this but I don't find them to be true. The hider has three ways to die each night, only one of which outs a wolf and only if the hider truthfully hypoclaims before targeting them. The other two methods lead to a dead hider and no out wolves. Given that added to the...

Indeed. As for the other post, motivation behind reaction trolling is going to be telling. But there's no way to do more than just speculate on somebody's motivation.

Super, very, totally, unclear. And this is why both KoD was so adamant that you didn't read my post correctly and that I haven't decided on your read yet. This one line shows that I have given strategic thought to the matter. But how many times did you bother to ask for clarity before deciding...

You're probably just reading me talking to like you aren't a priority lynch as me talking to like I think you're town.

And as I said that was by and large reactionary. Simply calling somebody scum doesn't make your statement a push. Given that he didn't even elaborate on why he called me scum initially, his actions are more indicative of not intending to push. A better estimate of his actions would be reaction...

Are you realistically calling what you're doing a push? I mean DW had to ask you for elaboration. And if KoD hadn't decided to throw hands with you I feel like it'd be more of a one off flash in the pan post. That said I don't think I'd attribute opportunistic to it either way. You didn't grasp...

Eh? I mean I can tell you you're barking up the wrong tree but coming from me that don't mean squat. Also I'm aware I come off as more wolf than not regardless of alignment. So to sum up *shrugs*

Here's where we differ Zie, I wholeheartedly agree with the above. But because of that I don't place all my chickens in one hider basket. As you say we could get lucky with mech info. But we might not. We could sweep scum without the hider ever claiming. They could die n1 clearing nobody...

Here's an idea I'd like to hear thoughts on and maybe possibly generate my entire day 1 reads list off of: What do you think of hider cover similar to the way some people seer/cop cover (ie, if I was a cop I would have peeked player X)? Personally I can't decide on where I'd put the...