After reading through again, I'm liking a P8 lynch. Jumping on the wagon because he didn't want a coin toss despite having very shady information (and so his vote was basically a coin toss anyway) seems strange as heck to me. But the point about saving P9 bring a strange thing if he's town is a...
Player 8 and 7 coming at the end of that wagon look suspicious to me. Player 7 admitting it looked bad and then doing it anyway... That's weird. Don't like it at all. Wouldn't be surprised if one of those two was scum.