Good job everyone! This was a great game and I had fun being scum for once. Haha.
I'll post some more of what I want to say later though, as my mind is a bit distracted at the moment.
It's actually 2 for Dom and 3 for YIGA since you removed your vote.
I've seen more scummy behavior from Dom, so that's where I'm going to place my vote. His claim as a vanilla is a really safe claim for mafia to make, and I feel like he and YIGA could be scumbuds anyways. I just get a much...
I'm still trying to figure out who I think is the best decision. While Dom did give a list of his reads, he didn't really expand upon why he thought the people in his town list were town and the people in his scum list were scum. His post explaining himself looks pretty good on the surface, but...
Okay, so here are my updated reads lists. I'll try to make it not as long as the last ones.
Town:
Miss Cucco
EMIYA
Bok (obvious, but he's still with us for now, so I'll put him on here as well)
Leaning town:
Jimmu
Mido
Neutral:
Ghirahim
Leaning scum:
karu
Mezlo
Scum:
Dom
YIGA
So, the most...
Dom and YIGA are both looking really suspicious right now. Both of their votes seem like an attempt to distance themselves from each other, and feel like they were more panicky votes since they've both been catching quite a bit of heat lately. I'll try to update my reads list soon, as they've...
Welcome Ghirahim! Nice to have you join us.
I'm going to go back and reread a few people that I'm unsure of at the moment and see if anything new stands out to me. Krow's death looks like an attempt by the mafia to frame Dom like others have said. Though maybe they realized that it would look...
At the time though, he was claiming a bomb role, so a vig shot on him at night would've taken out our vig as well (if there is one). So that wouldn't have been a very safe move if Storm had actually been telling the truth. I mean, we know now that he wasn't, but in the moment we were dealing...
I did consider that. But I did agree with the reasoning for voting Storm even though they felt he was a townie, as like others have said, that was anti-town behavior. And if we didn't lynch him, mafia would have left him for a huge distraction in the game, and we would just have to lynch him...
I did talk about him in my first post of the day, where I was trying to figure out the votes on Storm's lynch. He and karu have been two that have stood out to me for their actions on day 1, and funnier just seemed to look even worse today with his actions. I'll quote my post so you don't have...
With recent discussion, do you think there's a good lynch candidate now? I know you were suspicious of Dom, but are there any other people that seem suspicious to you?
It's nice to hear your explanation for this. While I was one who previously brought that up as feeling iffy about it, I find this to be a fairly decent reason. Though I didn't find you not removing your vote incredibly scummy in the first place, it was one of the things that stood out to me as...
Sorry I haven't posted much. Wasn't feeling super well today, so I just hadn't gotten around to putting together my thoughts yet.
First off, I wanna give my thoughts on the people I didn't address in my earlier post.
Domo- I have a very slight town read on him at the moment. I don't think his...
Welcome Krow, nice to see a new face around here!
Long post incoming. Sorry I haven't really been active today. I had started typing this a while ago and didn't get time to finish it then, so it kinda got long after I thought about stuff some more.
I gotta say I'm not a fan of karu hammering...
I'll have to re-read things again, to see if anything stands out, especially when it comes to the votes on Storm.
Though at the moment, I agree with something that Mido said early on in the game about it being interesting that Libk pointed out Storm's "claim" to begin with. That seems to have...
I understand all the votes on Storm, and definitely see why lynching him would be a pretty good option, but I also feel like we're rushing things a bit. Everyone is too focused on Storm at the moment, and if we go ahead with his lynch and he flips town we don't have a lot to go on from there...
I'm a bit confused about this whole roleclaim. Maybe it's because I'm not entirely familiar with the bomb role (only know what was talked about last game). Though it seems that with that role, whoever kills you at night goes down with you? And you're also claiming that the role is vengeful as...
That actually is what that movie is about, so the reference checks out!
Also, there must be something about Avatar themed games that cause us to get serious just a couple of pages in.