The chances for both of them to survive the first night are very low, because
1. Both of them need to infact be doctors.
2. Both of them need to agree to use this technique (do you?
@Malon @Storm).
3. There can't be a roleblocker in the mafia.
While I find your efforts to save both of them or at least get as much information as possible out of the scenario admirable, I disagree with your statement that only the mafia would benefit from having us lynch Storm or Malon today. To the contrary, if they have a roleblocker (and I think in a large game like this, it's highly likely that they do), the best course of action for them would be to lynch someone else today. This gives them:
1. A killed townie, potentially a powerrole if they get lucky.
2. An easy nightkill on the doctor, most likely Malon.
3. A town that will be convinced Storm is mafia and will lynch him on their own on Day 2.
It's in the mafia's best interest to keep suspicious town players alive, since those have the highest chance of being lynched by the town instead of one of their own.
With all that said, you do still make some pretty valid points, and seeing as I don't believe either of them to be mafia based on experience playing with them in the previous game, it might still be worthwile to go for it. The problem is, is there a good target to focus on? You've set your eyes on Pendio:
I can't say I'm completely sold on him to be honest. Pendio has quite the reputation around here, as do you by the way, so it's certainly feasible to suspect him of making a play like this as a scum member. I don't think there's enough grounds for a lynch, however, because his reasoning makes perfect sense for someone who has never played with Storm before, and just lynching him would potentially get rid of one of our strongest players - just what the mafia would like. Right, kokirion?
FoS: kokirion
