Hyrule Historia Collector’s Edition Selling for Huge Amounts on eBay

JohnFebruary 7th, 2013 by John

It’s hard to forget the amount of excitement which was generated by the fan community when the English translation of Hyrule Historia was announced. Even more overwhelming was the reaction to the announcement of the Collector’s Edition, limited to just 4,000 copies worldwide. However, while the standard edition of the book continues to storm the Amazon’s best sellers list, you won’t find the Collector’s Edition on any retail site on the net. Why so? Because after mere hours of the coveted book going on sale, the 4,000 copies worldwide were sold in a matter of hours, with retailers having to cancel numerous orders (mine included) due to the unprecedented demand. Despite this, there is still one place on the net where there is no shortage of the rare book. But before you jump onto eBay to purchase one for yourself you may want to look twice at just how much the book is selling for. Hit the jump to take a look!

This picture is from an auction which ended on the 5th of February and as you can see, the 14 bids culminated in the book selling for a huge $212.51, with an additional $5 for shipping. Already the price has inflated a good three and a half times what it sold for during the short period when it was on sale. But this seems like an almost reasonable deal compared to the lot below.

The second lot above has an auction starting at £150, which is around $234. Which is already more expensive than what the book went for in the first auction. Not only that however, but the Buy It Now option prices the book at a massive £250, which equates to around $391. For a book which originally had a selling price of around $60. Despite eBay’s reputation of being able to find good quality products for bargain-basement prices, it is evident that there are no bargains, basement or otherwise, to be found here.

Perhaps the worst part of this is the motivation behind why people would sell items like these for such prices. Aside from the design of the cover and the fact that the Collector’s Edition has gold gilded pages, the two versions are absolutely identical in content, which is pretty much the book’s main selling point. What we have here then is exploitation of the fact that people would pay huge amounts of money for something which is only valuable due its rarity. Besides the fact that the book is rare, there is no reason for it to be selling for such an inflated price and therefore no reason why it should be so desirable, unless one has a severe aversion to the standard edition cover. Perhaps I am missing something here as I am not a serious collector of merchandise but setting a price of £250 for an item like this seems incredibly unfair and selfish.

But what do you think? Would you fork out this amount of money for a Collector’s Edition? Have these sellers gone too far in terms of personal greed and profit? Tell us in the comments below!

Source: eBay

Share this post



  • link

    wow but i already got my new copy yaaaay

  • Pyrotek85

    I likely won’t. I was one of the people who had preordered the collector’s edition but had their order canceled without notification due to the inventory debacle that has gone on with it’s release. I’m just going to order the regular edition and enjoy that, but I’m still annoyed at how badly handled this went.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Akesha.nis Ake Sha

    Not surprised to see this. I’m glad I didn’t buy the collector edition ; even at 60$ it is far too expensive for was it offers.

    • Dandrago

      It’s actually down to $40ish for my amazon pre-order. Well worth the $20 extra in my opinion for 1 of 4000. I’m just kicking myself for not buying 2!

    • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

      Pre-orders on the collectors actually were only around $35-$40…. and considering I bet none of them ever made it to book store shelves no one who got it paid the listed $60 price tag for it.

  • person

    Ugh. That ‘massive’ £250/$391 is what that basic/white model of the wii u costs here in the UK.

  • CaffeineBomber

    I pre-ordered the collector’s edition on Amazon at the end of November. Got an email from them last week saying they couldn’t fulfill the order. Absolutely gutted. They shouldn’t be taking pre-orders if they can’t fulfill them . Will have to get the peasant version like everyone else.

    • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

      Had this happen from 5 distributors… I feel your pain and frustration.

  • itsameluigi1290

    Dang, my wallet can’t hold that much. *Goes Skulltula hunting*

  • Hero_of_Skyloft

    I bet Mases has the collector’s edition

    • Nepenthe

      Haha bet he does~!
      Maybe he’ll show it off.

  • http://www.facebook.com/RyanF.Hullstrunk Ryan F. Hullstrunk

    If I had the money I’d pay that much for something like this. It’s more then worth it in my eyes

    • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

      *than

      • Tired

        **
        (Get it yet? No? It’s a space. Because you put underspaces instead of spaces. Next time go with xXswagalicious360noscopeXx)

        • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

          I was actually correcting his grammar, where you put “then” where he should have put “than.” I have no idea what you’re talking about.

          • Dovahliink

            He’s correcting your username’s grammar. He’s just saying that you could have used spaces instead of underscores.

          • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

            Ah. Except (note: not accept, grammar n00bs [yes that is the proper spelling of it]) that I couldn’t, because at the time, Disqus rules wouldn’t let me put spaces. I tried. The n00b.

        • http://www.facebook.com/haley.carra.1 Haley Carra

          underscores* Not underspaces, smart one.

  • Ness1985

    I hate the greedy f*ckers of ebay.

  • ThePieOfTruth

    i preordered the collector’s addition BUT, of course, barnes and noble would be a piece of crap and lose all my order info. oh well. I’m still getting hyrule historia either way and i will enjoy it all the same!

    • http://twitter.com/DarkMachi DarkMachi

      The same thing happened to me :’(

      • gamer

        Same here, I have a feeling Barnes and Noble over booked and “lost” them to save face the best they could. I had ordered both, but now won’t get the collectors addition, because there is no way I’m paying that much for one. Never using Barnes and Noble again.

  • Ordona

    I hate people that buy things like this only with the intention of selling them later for a huge profit. There’s nothing you can do and in the end the fans either miss out or are exploited out of obscene amounts of money. I’m happy with my regular edition – it’s the content I’m interested in.

    • Guest

      People do the same thing with concert tickets. I saw a band this past weekend, and by the time my friends realized they could go after all, the show was sold out–except for the people scalping them online for triple or quadruple the original price. It’s just a crappy thing to do when there are real fans out there, whether it be a concert or a cool video game book.

      • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

        Concert’s are different but the concept is the same. It’s straight up scalping….

        Scalping Concert’s tickets (or sporting event or some other event) has a risk to it though. If you don’t sell your tickets before the concert or event you lose your money. In the end most scalpers will cut you a deal if it’s the day of the event, as most scalpers will sell it for a cheaper price if they can at least make up for a loss.

        When it comes to collectors items, and memorabilia it’s generally is a safe investment… a valuable item/collectible will usually retain it’s value it not escalate in value. It’s not like the event will expire and you lose everything.

        • Kravik

          I almost bought an extra copy of the limited 3DS Zelda bundle..
          My morality says I did the right thing, not getting a extra..

          But my wallet says I am FREAKING STUPID! For not doing so…

      • Ordona

        Don’t talk to me about concert tickets, I’ve been trying to see Green Day for the past eight years. >.<

    • http://www.youtube.com/user/bs88145 bs8814

      True dat

  • Kravik

    Seems all new Zelda articles these days turn to gold… (It is sick that people pay these prices though.)

    • Oldish

      Kind of fair, actually.

      • Link master

        Leave a message…its a shame to do such a thing you can tell who the ”true” fans are from the deceivers

        • Kravik

          Easy money though.. I almost did it myself..

  • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

    They didn’t set the price. The first one was an AUCTION and people were willing to pay that. If I had known about the collectors edition sooner, I would have done the same thing: but 3 or more copies, one for me, one to sell now to pay off the other 2, and one to sell later for an even higher price. Just be glad it’s still possible to get them.

  • Kevin Yaniak

    They will reprint more at some point, I wouldn’t worry about it.

  • M2-Wes

    ThinkGeek had theirs on sale 4 days ago and I mangaged to get a couple copies of the limited edition. They are coming today via UPS!!

    • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

      “couple of copies of the Limited Edition” and this is exactly what I was talking about.

      • LOL U DIDNT GET A COPY

        oh yeah, your the guy who complained a whole lot on dark horses’s blog cuz u couldnt get a limited edition copy. boo hoo

        • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

          Wasn’t the only one, there was plenty of others disappointed, actual fans who would’ve appreciated what they purchased.

          Not looking to exploit other people.

  • CourageBringsSuccess

    eBay has no shortage of absurdly overpriced Zelda merchandise. Especially anything branded as a “Collector’s” item, whether or not it was intended to be one.

    All I know is that I certainly don’t regret my $20 preorder/purchase of the standard Hyrule Historia from Barnes & Noble, particularly after seeing this article.

  • Merv?

    What’s so different between the collector’s edition and the normal version?

    • http://ZeldaDungeon.net/ Jordan D.

      Collector’s has a brown, faux-leather cover (as opposed to the normal edition’s Book of Mudora green cover) and gilded edges on the pages.
      …And that’s literally the only difference.

      • Liquidus

        Also the Collector’s Edition has no golden imprint on the cover like the standard edition has lol

        • Merv?

          Wow. I think I know what version I’m getting.

  • http://www.facebook.com/DarthDiclonius Alexander Tischler

    I forgot I had purchased the standard edition when pre-order first started, so I went ahead and pre-ordered the collector’s edition too. I now own both.

  • Rupee

    I fucking hate those people. Disgusting.

  • Twister27

    I agree that it is absurd, but if people are willing to pay over $200 for the book, you can’t really blame the people selling it for that price. No one is forcing the buyers to spend that much; it is only at that price because that is what people think it is worth.

    For the people who don’t value it that highly, there is still the option of simply buying the standard edition.

    • http://www.facebook.com/haley.carra.1 Haley Carra

      I would like to correct your statement there. The seller gets to choose what price the bidding starts at. For all we know, the seller started it at $198.51, and each bidder only bid up by a dollar.

      • GoMikeD

        Now I feel I have to correct your statement here, that is not “all we know” you can always see where the seller starts their price at every auction and some even start theirs at 99 cents, because it doesn’t matter, the only one that matters is the final ending price, you can start the price anywhere and people are going to bid what they’re willing to pay, plain and simple

        So if people want to be angry with someone, they need to take their anger out on the buyers, because if no one would place a $300+ bid then guess what, they wouldn’t be selling for that much

        Buyers drive up the prices, not sellers

        • http://www.facebook.com/haley.carra.1 Haley Carra

          I know that. You completely missed my point, however. .__.

  • Mikau94

    I hate re-sellers

    • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

      Just be glad the do re-sell. You could get it for an insane price from re-sellers, or not get it at all. Hmmm…..

      • Mikau94

        True, but I already have mine, so I feel bad for people who expected to be able to go out and buy this but the re-sellers got there first.

        • Link_The_Ultimate_Chronomancer

          Yeah, but as I see it, this is more fair. Now the people who want it the most get it. Don’t want it? Don’t pay an insane price for it.

          • http://www.facebook.com/daniel.nash1 Daniel Taylor Nash

            Morally twisted

  • http://twitter.com/MagicalRamen Rin Okumura

    If this was a book printed in Hyrule and signed by Zelda herself, maybe I’d pay that much for it.

  • http://twitter.com/HEXONE4LIFE Daniel Santiago

    I would love to own this Collector edition. I’m good with the Non Collectors edition though.

  • http://twitter.com/mikejcsauer Mike Sauer

    I spent $35 on the Collector’s Edition Pre-order back in august from Barnes & Noble.

    • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

      Yeah that’s the disgusting bit… pre-orders on the Collectors Editions were cheap… only $15 more then the regular edition. It wouldn’t have been hard for a scalper to order 3 copies for under $100…. keep one, sell the other two, make $350 profit.

      My pre-order from Barnes & Noble was cancelled a month after I ordered it… they didn’t even send a notice or e-mail had to figure it out myself.

  • NinjaApe

    How much is that in rupees?

  • Christburner

    cool..people are starving in some parts in the world and this asshole paid 200 for a book. great.

    • Mikau94

      You just described college.

  • http://www.controlpaddesign.com/ TheMaverickk

    Yeah don’t get me started about the Limited Edition.

    I’m pretty disgusted at what Dark Horse did.

    What was worse is the fact that no one who pre-ordered the book back in August probably caught that the opened up pre-orders for the Limited Edition 2-3 months after the initial orders opened up.

    What is worse is that both Dark Horse and various distributers bungled hard. I tried to get in on the Limited Edition. I had 5 pre-orders cancelled over the course of 2-3 months. Why? Cause apparently even distributors had no idea how many copies they were going to have. It was a frustrating ordeal and at the end of it all no Limited Edition.

    I didn’t even want it in order to sell and make profit, purely for the sole reason of enjoying it as a fan. Not to mention knowing how bad scalpers are for snagging these sorts of goods. It’s why there are already numerous listings selling the book at $150+

    Mind you neither Dark Horse nor any of the distributors did anything at all to discourage scalpers. A lot of websites are able to put restrictions on orders, usually something along the lines of one copy per address. To prevent people from snagging multiples easy. Yet no such restrictions were done.

    Also at the end of the day I’m just peeved Dark Horse released two versions. It serves no purpose other then to make people with the regular edition feel dissatisfied with their purchase. Had they left well enough alone and had all the books the same across the board it would’ve been better. Now I’m simply left with a bad taste in my mouth over the ordeal. It’s not just Dark Horse though… those people selling on eBay are just as bad…. I’ll shame anyone who takes advantage of or exploits a fan base for their own greed and profit.

  • Hyrule’s Prophet

    If I had the money, I would definitely get it, but as Ordona said, why in the world would you need to buy something this rare and precious to some people, just so you could get rid of it. Some people actually want this thing to cherish and keep forever. I am one of those people, and I am ashamed that this kind of thing is happening.

  • bladcf

    lol Zelda/ Nintendo collectors are notorious for horribly overpricing things like this.

  • Anonymous

    “What we have here then is exploitation of the fact that people would pay
    huge amounts of money for something which is only valuable due its
    rarity. Besides the fact that the book is rare, there is no reason for
    it to be selling for such an inflated price and therefore no reason why
    it should be so desirable, unless one has a severe aversion to the
    standard edition cover. Perhaps I am missing something here as I am not a
    serious collector of merchandise but setting a price of £250 for an
    item like this seems incredibly unfair and selfish.”

    That’s idiotic. First of all, isn’t that what the publisher is doing? Planning scarcity and selling the special edition for double? Is this an inherent criticism of the very concept of special editions? Second, everything on the market derives value from its rarity. Thirdly, these sellers serve an important purpose in delaying purchasing for long-term possession for the spread of information amongst consumers, enabling a wider base of more hard-core fans the ability to own.

  • http://twitter.com/SongOStorms Sarah

    I pre ordered the collectors edition as soon as it became available from Amazon, however it looks like I won’t be getting a copy now as it seems all their stock has shipped. They haven’t cancelled my order however pretty much everyone has received them. I’m very disappointed by this however I won’t be paying the ridiculous Ebay prices instead I’ll stick with the standard edition.

  • phaedruss

    Lol you don’t understand economics, collectibles, or much of anything, huh?

  • Pingback: Man buys 45 copies of Hyrule Historia Limited Edition, sells on Craigslist

  • Pingback: Zelda | Man buys 45 copies of Hyrule Historia Limited Edition, sells on Craigslist | Zelda